Making use of a high IQ
Mummy_of_Peanut wrote:
I'm frustrated, to put it mildly. I did well at school, everything was easy and I got a degree in microbiology, without a great deal of effort (I had real difficulty trying to study, so I basically didn't study much at all). However, I left with my ordinary degree, as I had social anxiety and dreaded what the 4th year required of me, not academically. Then, I went on to do a taught post-grad course in environmental studies, which involved a work placement, which I did in the energy management section of the local council. The work was admin and I was kept on as employee, after my course ended. There I stayed for the next 11 years. I got one promotion and moved around, due to staffing reviews, but I never progressed any.
I always felt I was in the wrong job and started to teach myself IT skills, that were not essential for my job, but helped me to do my job better. My boss took note of what I knew and put me to work, designing databases and advanced analytical spreadsheets. So there I was, doing the same stuff as some of the IT staff (as well as my regular duties), but being paid as an admin assistant. When it came to my reviews, my boss would kind of mention that I was amazing at these things and indispensible, but the main topic of conversation was my supervisory/ communication deficits. Of all the admin assistants, I was the only one who got assessed as being 'fair', the others were 'good' or 'excellent'. This really affected my self esteem. I also felt taken for granted, in relation to all the high level work I was doing, which no-one else could even begin to comprehend. Before I left, a new system was being brought in and my databases had to be converted over, by IT. I had loads of compliments from IT about my work, who were amazed that I'd taught myself and they had even learned something, from studying them. That confirmed it for me that I really was as good as I suspected.
When my daughter was born, I decided I'd had enough of the place, so I never went back after maternity leave. I've not worked for 6 1/2 years, except for some voluntary work, including moderating this site. My special interests are in health, nutrition, genetics, natural and ancient therapies, etc, but I'm lost as to how to take this forward into a career. I also have those IT skills, which I could go back to, but I don't have a qualification in IT and have been considering doing a qualification at home. I've also toyed with the idea of perfecting my art skills, but I'm not good enough to make a decent living, unless I can be inventive. I need to think about what I want to do with the rest of my life, because I'm going round in circles and getting nowhere.
I always felt I was in the wrong job and started to teach myself IT skills, that were not essential for my job, but helped me to do my job better. My boss took note of what I knew and put me to work, designing databases and advanced analytical spreadsheets. So there I was, doing the same stuff as some of the IT staff (as well as my regular duties), but being paid as an admin assistant. When it came to my reviews, my boss would kind of mention that I was amazing at these things and indispensible, but the main topic of conversation was my supervisory/ communication deficits. Of all the admin assistants, I was the only one who got assessed as being 'fair', the others were 'good' or 'excellent'. This really affected my self esteem. I also felt taken for granted, in relation to all the high level work I was doing, which no-one else could even begin to comprehend. Before I left, a new system was being brought in and my databases had to be converted over, by IT. I had loads of compliments from IT about my work, who were amazed that I'd taught myself and they had even learned something, from studying them. That confirmed it for me that I really was as good as I suspected.
When my daughter was born, I decided I'd had enough of the place, so I never went back after maternity leave. I've not worked for 6 1/2 years, except for some voluntary work, including moderating this site. My special interests are in health, nutrition, genetics, natural and ancient therapies, etc, but I'm lost as to how to take this forward into a career. I also have those IT skills, which I could go back to, but I don't have a qualification in IT and have been considering doing a qualification at home. I've also toyed with the idea of perfecting my art skills, but I'm not good enough to make a decent living, unless I can be inventive. I need to think about what I want to do with the rest of my life, because I'm going round in circles and getting nowhere.
I don't really get why you would be frustrated. When I was in school, for some reason, I basically had to work intensely for whatever grades I made. It seemed I couldn't learn anything without studying. I fantasize of having the kind of job success you had and the respect you earned. I've had nothing but menial jobs and a mediocre office job which I just ran away from. Due to my incompetence, I didn't get to do any tasks more advanced than adding up numbers, and dealt with a supervisor who took advantage of my weaknesses through being mean to me and laughing behind my back with others, eventually passing me over for some guy who came from another department after having had a temper tantrum with his boss. I wonder if I'll ever make anything valuable come out of the investment put into my education.
I have a relatively high IQ and i'm even a member of Mensa.
Being that you have AS, I would suggest studying a subject in college that is corollary to a special interest you may have. I have always loved taking apart electronics, so i'm majoring in computer science.
_________________
Your Aspie score: 159 of 200
Your neurotypical (non-autistic) score: 51 of 200
You are very likely an Aspie
Mummy_of_Peanut
Veteran
Joined: 20 Feb 2011
Age: 51
Gender: Female
Posts: 3,564
Location: Bonnie Scotland
dalurker wrote:
I don't really get why you would be frustrated. When I was in school, for some reason, I basically had to work intensely for whatever grades I made. It seemed I couldn't learn anything without studying. I fantasize of having the kind of job success you had and the respect you earned. I've had nothing but menial jobs and a mediocre office job which I just ran away from. Due to my incompetence, I didn't get to do any tasks more advanced than adding up numbers, and dealt with a supervisor who took advantage of my weaknesses through being mean to me and laughing behind my back with others, eventually passing me over for some guy who came from another department after having had a temper tantrum with his boss. I wonder if I'll ever make anything valuable come out of the investment put into my education.
But, I had no success and no respect. The job I was doing, I could have done without any post school qualifications whatsoever (most of my colleagues hadn't even been to college). I wasted 4 years, getting a degree and a post grad. Then, I ended up in a low paid admin job (I wasn't earning that much more than the staff I supervised), which was completely unrelated to my qualifications. In effect, I was 4 years behind my peers, who had achieved much less at school. They are really the successful ones, not me. As I said, my boss made a much bigger issue out of the things I wasn't so good at and took advantage of my good nature. I was taken aside several times for my inadequacy and the discussions ended with me in tears. I was complimented by IT staff for my work, but by that time I was heading for maternity leave and those guys were in no position to offer me a way out either. I have made nothing valuable come out of my education so far and I'm 39. As for me saying that I didn't study, I can't study. I can't even read a book, unless my intense interest has been captured by the first paragraph. I wish I could study.
_________________
"We act as though comfort and luxury were the chief requirements of life, when all we need to make us really happy is something to be enthusiatic about." Charles Kingsley
Mummy_of_Peanut wrote:
But, I had no success and no respect. The job I was doing, I could have done without any post school qualifications whatsoever (most of my colleagues hadn't even been to college). I wasted 4 years, getting a degree and a post grad. Then, I ended up in a low paid admin job (I wasn't earning that much more than the staff I supervised), which was completely unrelated to my qualifications. In effect, I was 4 years behind my peers, who had achieved much less at school. They are really the successful ones, not me. As I said, my boss made a much bigger issue out of the things I wasn't so good at and took advantage of my good nature. I was taken aside several times for my inadequacy and the discussions ended with me in tears. I was complimented by IT staff for my work, but by that time I was heading for maternity leave and those guys were in no position to offer me a way out either. I have made nothing valuable come out of my education so far and I'm 39. As for me saying that I didn't study, I can't study. I can't even read a book, unless my intense interest has been captured by the first paragraph. I wish I could study.
Why didn't you pursue a job that would be based on what you were educated in? What if there are job openings in which the kind of work you did at the admin job, is highly compensated?
NarcissusSavage wrote:
Greb wrote:
I agree with most of what have been said here. Though, basically, I don't see where the problem is.
One of the problems of having a 'special interest' is that you're useless out of it: you can't focus, you're not really interested, your mind don't keep knowledge (because she considers it not worthy enough to be kept), and that doesn't change no matter how much effort you do to focus and to learn. So, at the end, doing something that lies outside of your 'special interest' is exhausting and highly unproductive. That's because it's recommended to find a maketeable skill that lies inside your 'special interest'. You will be much happier and much more succesful.
But if you don't have a 'special interest' it means that you focus in what you decide without problems, just like any NT person. So, where do you find problems?
One of the problems of having a 'special interest' is that you're useless out of it: you can't focus, you're not really interested, your mind don't keep knowledge (because she considers it not worthy enough to be kept), and that doesn't change no matter how much effort you do to focus and to learn. So, at the end, doing something that lies outside of your 'special interest' is exhausting and highly unproductive. That's because it's recommended to find a maketeable skill that lies inside your 'special interest'. You will be much happier and much more succesful.
But if you don't have a 'special interest' it means that you focus in what you decide without problems, just like any NT person. So, where do you find problems?
There is a difference in doing work that falls within your special interests, and doing something important to you that can utilize skills gained from your special interests. I recommend the latter.
Interesting. I think I could have done this in my profession / job. Could you write an example? For me, one of my interests was computers and programming. Now I work in finances, and I sometimes write code, work with databases and use spreadsheets. I was also good at algebra.
dalurker wrote:
I don't really get why you would be frustrated. When I was in school, for some reason, I basically had to work intensely for whatever grades I made. It seemed I couldn't learn anything without studying. I fantasize of having the kind of job success you had and the respect you earned. I've had nothing but menial jobs and a mediocre office job which I just ran away from. Due to my incompetence, I didn't get to do any tasks more advanced than adding up numbers, and dealt with a supervisor who took advantage of my weaknesses through being mean to me and laughing behind my back with others, eventually passing me over for some guy who came from another department after having had a temper tantrum with his boss. I wonder if I'll ever make anything valuable come out of the investment put into my education.
dalurker, isn't this thread for Aspie's with high IQs, not average IQs?
Anyway your bitterness seems out-of-place in a thread where posters are seeking guidance and advice.
I have a relatively high IQ and most subjects -- at least non-science courses -- in school came relatively easy to me too. So I can relate to some of the posters here, as I said the same thing recently to my friend with the PhD in Special Ed who asked if I had Aspergers. Told him: "I've never been able to make my IQ work for me."
Anyway I'm thinking that maybe it's females with AS who have an especially difficult time in adjusting to the workplace. Really I don't know. But from this thread, I get the impression that the majority of posters who are voicing failure with respect to their high IQs and job happiness are females.
Bunnynose wrote:
dalurker, isn't this thread for Aspie's with high IQs, not average IQs?
Anyway your bitterness seems out-of-place in a thread where posters are seeking guidance and advice.
I have a relatively high IQ and most subjects -- at least non-science courses -- in school came relatively easy to me too. So I can relate to some of the posters here, as I said the same thing recently to my friend with the PhD in Special Ed who asked if I had Aspergers. Told him: "I've never been able to make my IQ work for me."
I'm just commenting on a thread regarding the topic. Nothing I said or asked of their situations would be contrary to success for them. I'm not against advice. Due to my lower strengths, I have been led to only follow orders and direction, as it couldn't matter that I devoted years to learning things. I decided to question the dominant people out there for a change. Someone has to say something when there are very successful individuals complaining as if they're unfortunate, due to them not choosing to keep careers. There is just too much sympathy out there for those who already have the means to help themselves.
Quote:
Anyway I'm thinking that maybe it's females with AS who have an especially difficult time in adjusting to the workplace. Really I don't know. But from this thread, I get the impression that the majority of posters who are voicing failure with respect to their high IQs and job happiness are females.
It's not. You are not having an especially difficult time.
dalurker wrote:
I'm just commenting on a thread regarding the topic. Nothing I said or asked of their situations would be contrary to success for them. I'm not against advice. Due to my lower strengths, I have been led to only follow orders and direction, as it couldn't matter that I devoted years to learning things. I decided to question the dominant people out there for a change. Someone has to say something when there are very successful individuals complaining as if they're unfortunate, due to them not choosing to keep careers. There is just too much sympathy out there for those who already have the means to help themselves.
But high IQ doesn't mean that people has the means to help themselves. High IQ doesn't mean that people are dominant, or that people can do more than follow directions. High IQ doesn't even mean that people can follow directions.
Doing well in school doesn't at all mean that people will do well in the workplace, or even that they'll get a job at all. Yes, I have a high IQ, you're far ahead of me in your success at work.
Tuttle wrote:
But high IQ doesn't mean that people has the means to help themselves. High IQ doesn't mean that people are dominant, or that people can do more than follow directions. High IQ doesn't even mean that people can follow directions.
Doing well in school doesn't at all mean that people will do well in the workplace, or even that they'll get a job at all. Yes, I have a high IQ, you're far ahead of me in your success at work.
Doing well in school doesn't at all mean that people will do well in the workplace, or even that they'll get a job at all. Yes, I have a high IQ, you're far ahead of me in your success at work.
I'm thinking of those around me in general, as being dominant. I've heard claims that IQ doesn't guarantee academic success, then I hear that having both high IQ and academic success doesn't guarantee job success. Look, I just don't fundamentally buy these claims. Undergoing an IQ test itself requires following directions.
dalurker wrote:
Bunnynose wrote:
dalurker, isn't this thread for Aspie's with high IQs, not average IQs?
Anyway your bitterness seems out-of-place in a thread where posters are seeking guidance and advice.
I have a relatively high IQ and most subjects -- at least non-science courses -- in school came relatively easy to me too. So I can relate to some of the posters here, as I said the same thing recently to my friend with the PhD in Special Ed who asked if I had Aspergers. Told him: "I've never been able to make my IQ work for me."
I'm just commenting on a thread regarding the topic. Nothing I said or asked of their situations would be contrary to success for them. I'm not against advice. Due to my lower strengths, I have been led to only follow orders and direction, as it couldn't matter that I devoted years to learning things. I decided to question the dominant people out there for a change. Someone has to say something when there are very successful individuals complaining as if they're unfortunate, due to them not choosing to keep careers. There is just too much sympathy out there for those who already have the means to help themselves.
Quote:
Anyway I'm thinking that maybe it's females with AS who have an especially difficult time in adjusting to the workplace. Really I don't know. But from this thread, I get the impression that the majority of posters who are voicing failure with respect to their high IQs and job happiness are females.
It's not. You are not having an especially difficult time.
It's not a matter of sympathy, dalurker. Folks are asking others a way to a kind of happiness with regard to working. You have stated you haven't found it and they have stated that they haven't found it. With those of us with higher-than-average IQs, we are/were expected to find and keep the right jobs/careers. It's these expectations and the early promise that we've failed to realize. So finding the right career success has nothing to do with IQ but like what another poster previously wrote -- drive. I'm going to guess that loving that job is the other intangible thing that has eluded us.
And you guessed wrong yet again. (Honestly, dalurker, assuming and projecting are two mind-messing things we all can break. I know I struggle with both still.) Just a few minutes ago while listening to Waylon Jennings' "Dream On" on a loop, I was thinking I should be in some bar, getting drunk because I can't seem to find a job that fits my talents and smarts (but can't because I'm broke, prefer staying home, and prefer getting drunk in social settings). And because the one job I do want, and have waited for months to hear from and finally did get a call last Wednesday to fill out and turn in my answers to a lengthy questionnaire, I might not get because of my crappy job history. The last real job I had, I quit on the third morning because the boss was an arbitrary bully. And I'm sure he'll have some nasty things to say about me when the call comes in to his office.
dalurker wrote:
Tuttle wrote:
But high IQ doesn't mean that people has the means to help themselves. High IQ doesn't mean that people are dominant, or that people can do more than follow directions. High IQ doesn't even mean that people can follow directions.
Doing well in school doesn't at all mean that people will do well in the workplace, or even that they'll get a job at all. Yes, I have a high IQ, you're far ahead of me in your success at work.
Doing well in school doesn't at all mean that people will do well in the workplace, or even that they'll get a job at all. Yes, I have a high IQ, you're far ahead of me in your success at work.
I'm thinking of those around me in general, as being dominant. I've heard claims that IQ doesn't guarantee academic success, then if i hear that having high IQ and academic success doesn't guarantee job success. Look, I just don't fundamentally buy these claims. Undergoing an IQ test itself requires following directions.
Personally, I have high IQ and academic success and vocational rehab is considering me a very difficult case which they aren't even the slightest bit hopeful that they'll find me a placement within a year (they have about 80% placement within a year, I first got on their waitlist a year ago and they still don't think there's a reasonable chance of placement within a year from now.)
I know plenty of people with high IQ and no academic success. The gifted underachiever is a rather well known to exist group of people among people who work with those with high IQ.
The gifted underachiever isn't even a subset of 2e kids though, its gifted overall. These people aren't even disabled and aren't achieving despite having the high IQ.
Those of us here, and other people who are 2e, then layer on top of that disability. It doesn't matter that I'm gifted when it comes to finding a job out of college when my disability holds me back.
And yes, IQ tests require following directions - one or two steps. People with executive functioning disorders, might not be able to keep track of 6 steps though, even with a high IQ. Directions can be given in drastically different manners. I can follow easily "put these together in the shape shown", but not "paint a reasonable amount outside of the border on the edge". "Define the word I say as quickly as you can" is far easier than "mix some of each of these spices".
People are more than a number. Life isn't fundamentally easier for us because we have a high IQ. Jobs aren't fundamentally easier. It's not necessarily easier for us to have success.
Yes, on average, people with higher IQs will have more education, get better jobs, succeed at them, and be able to go through and do things like pay for better education for their children, who also tend to have higher IQs.
That doesn't mean at all that its the case for every person with a higher IQ. It is especially not necessarily the case when adding a disability that does have huge effects on all parts of the person's life.
People with high IQs do have one advantage over you. It's just not an advantage or disadvantage that makes or breaks the ability to be successful at a job.
Mummy_of_Peanut wrote:
In effect, I was 4 years behind my peers, who had achieved much less at school. They are really the successful ones, not me.
Well, I'm exactly your age and about 20 years behind my peers, so to me, you're very succesful. I'd cut my left arm off to be only 4 years behind. Literally.
Quote:
I've not worked for 6 1/2 years
Well that's pretty rough, I suppose, at least I am working. Part time anyway. But I would kill for the options you have.
Kjas
Veteran
Joined: 26 Feb 2012
Age: 35
Gender: Female
Posts: 6,059
Location: the place I'm from doesn't exist anymore
dalurker wrote:
[I'm thinking of those around me in general, as being dominant. I've heard claims that IQ doesn't guarantee academic success, then I hear that having both high IQ and academic success doesn't guarantee job success. Look, I just don't fundamentally buy these claims. Undergoing an IQ test itself requires following directions.
The directions in it are simple, a few steps at most, we are not required to memorize 12 different verbal directions and then perform them flawlessly an hour later like you would in a job.
All IQ is, is your academic cognitive abilities. Nothing more, nothing less.
You may have very high score in some areas of it and very low scores in others. Some of us come out with high performance IQ and low verbal IQ.
You also have to remember you are dealing here with people with at least one "condition / disability" and some of us also have more than one. Taking executive functioning, sensory and attention issues into consideration alone, means that we may not necessary succeed as easily nor as well as expected.
IQ does not account for motivation, passion, or persistence. Or any character trait really.
In jobs you are often expected to have some instinctual social knowledge which we often lack. This adds to it, and even if you can do your job well, you may not get the necessary respect, promotions, raises etc that one would expect.
It's not as simple as "you have a high IQ therefore you will succeed". The real world doesn't work like that.
_________________
Diagnostic Tools and Resources for Women with AS: http://www.wrongplanet.net/postt211004.html
Bunnynose wrote:
So finding the right career success has nothing to do with IQ but like what another poster previously wrote -- drive.
So then, I didn't attain any job success because I'm lazy. Since there's no difference/advantage between me and someone with a high IQ. It's been proven I just don't want to work. I have you all figured out. You can't browbeat me again. Neither can that busybody supervisor who I don't have to see anymore.
Kjas wrote:
The directions in it are simple, a few steps at most, we are not required to memorize 12 different verbal directions and then perform them flawlessly an hour later like you would in a job.
Quote:
You may have very high score in some areas of it and very low scores in others. Some of us come out with high performance IQ and low verbal IQ.
Yeah, that complication exists.
Quote:
IQ does not account for motivation, passion, or persistence. Or any character trait really.
So who lacks the motivation and passion? I personally am near ready to stop trying all together. There's no reward or honor in trying if the actual possibility of success isn't there. I just end up being the incorrigible creep. I'm considering just becoming some kind of bum or drifter. I'm tired of trying to be decent and trying to prove myself when I know I never can.
Quote:
In jobs you are often expected to have some instinctual social knowledge which we often lack. This adds to it, and even if you can do your job well, you may not get the necessary respect, promotions, raises etc that one would expect.
If one is doing the job right, then they don't have those mentioned problems following directions. I myself couldn't do my job right, and consequently had no chance.
Similar Topics | |
---|---|
Customers making fun of me |
28 Sep 2024, 5:43 am |
Certain sounds are making me feel more irritable - Why? |
17 Sep 2024, 7:27 am |
high maintenance |
24 Aug 2024, 10:06 pm |
Anything Else I Should Consider With High Scores? |
18 Sep 2024, 10:05 pm |