i would definitely take it, but with some reserves.
i disagree with the notion that it takes away who you are and your personality. in the core we are who we are, and turning NT doesn't mean that will be taken away. Most of the people here describe aspie living as a set of traits. So, traits are not you, traits are for the most part something beside you. And most of these traits concern the inability to understand NT world and to function socially (even then it's a reduced number of traits that would change). So by taking the pill you basically start understanding people and connecting with them. You can make friends more easily and work with a broader range of emotions and experience them fully. Beyond that, it is still your decision if you want to change your views of the world. I think what you are, what you like, what you love to do etc. doesnt change. This is not a "personality makeover" pill. The only difference is you are more subject to social influence, but even then you can be in control if you choose to.
Most of us spend the day being angry and posting here about how i cant make a friend, i can't relate to people on my job, i cant... i cant...etc. And then when someone offers us a pill (even if its imaginary) to change all that, you reject it.
sure, you would lose some super analytical skills and a couple other things. but imho i think life is mostly about living and experiencing things, not thinking about them.