Why I have to be honest and disagree with some on this board
btbnnyr
Veteran
Joined: 18 May 2011
Gender: Female
Posts: 7,359
Location: Lost Angleles Carmen Santiago
When receiving criticism about myself like the criticism from the physician, how I receive the criticism can influence how I make decisions about myself and my life.
I can push against the criticism from the physician and focus on their behavior as inappropriate and unprofessional, or I can focus on myself and consider my own thoughts and actions and how they influence my life in the context of the criticism from the physician. How I think and what I do in response to the criticism can make the difference between me being in Situation X or Situation Y ten years from now. Do I continue as I am in my comfort zone, or do I try to study or work or make a life for myself, knowing that it will be hard and I will struggle? If I take the criticism a certain way and make a certain decision now, then it will be my personal responsibility, my own fault, if I regret my decision in the future.
_________________
Drain and plane and grain and blain your brain, and then again,
Propane and butane out of the gas main, your blain shall sustain!
This, I agree with this totally. I think it's one of the things that just bothers me the most about all of this. The "if you're not working, you're just a worthless moocher" attitude that so many people in this country have. I cant count the number of times I had to put up with people telling me that sort of thing years ago. Because, you know, working somewhere like a damn McDonalds would have made me just SO amazingly worthy.
And the times when I was pressed into the godforsaken search for one hellish job after another did me NO good whatsoever. Accomplished NOTHING. Not even once.... not ONCE.... did I ever get anything remotely positive out of ANY of those years of bloody stupidity. Heck, it seriously didnt take long at all before I just stopped giving a damn about the money that came from it. As far as I was concerned, it wasnt even CLOSE to worth it. And that was awhile ago, back when I actually did need the stupid cash. The jobs just caused that darned much miserableness.
Frankly, someone could offer me $80 an hour for a job like that, and I'd still turn it down, and probably throw something at them.
If a young person (let's say they're NT, and have no disabilities) prefers for whatever reason to live with their parents, and their parents are willing to support them financially, and everyone is happy with this arrangement... I really don't see how it's anyone's business to judge how they live their lives.
Especially since our current economy is one of rampant unemployment – so by not working, they're leaving a job open for someone who desperately needs it. Looking at it that way, they're actually doing society a favor by not working.
I don't condone young adults mooching off their parents for no good reason, especially if the parents want them to move out and get a job. But in the case where someone has legitimate difficulties working, and their parents are willing to help them out financially, and it's a decision they all agree upon, as a family... I honestly don't see a problem with that, and would respect their choice.
I agree that it's important for people to make the most of their lives. But there are many ways to find meaning and happiness in life, and proving one's competence at a job is not the only way.
Aye, this too. And most people never seem to think this way, ever.
If a young person (let's say they're NT, and have no disabilities) prefers for whatever reason to live with their parents, and their parents are willing to support them financially, and everyone is happy with this arrangement... I really don't see how it's anyone's business to judge how they live their lives.
Especially since our current economy is one of rampant unemployment – so by not working, they're leaving a job open for someone who desperately needs it. Looking at it that way, they're actually doing society a favor by not working.
I don't condone young adults mooching off their parents for no good reason, especially if the parents want them to move out and get a job. But in the case where someone has legitimate difficulties working, and their parents are willing to help them out financially, and it's a decision they all agree upon, as a family... I honestly don't see a problem with that, and would respect their choice.
I agree that it's important for people to make the most of their lives. But there are many ways to find meaning and happiness in life, and proving one's competence at a job is not the only way.
I wish my Prime Minister saw it that way. I fear he will kick me off the pension and have me work for the dole. Do basic menial jobs that do nothing to increase my skills or chances of getting a job I can flourish at.
I think a job would give me more confidence. I would just rather doing something that I'm good at and love.
_________________
My band photography blog - http://lostthroughthelens.wordpress.com/
My personal blog - http://helptheywantmetosocialise.wordpress.com/
I'm not on disability and am not even diagnosed but I was still never able to work and the couple of short times I did it was no where near enough to live on, not even with a roommate which I wouldn't do because I couldn't stand to live with some stranger.
When my mother is gone if she can't leave me enough to keep me going for a while and I can't get disability (which is not enough to live on) I'll end up homeless and may as well be dead.
"You gotta do what you gotta do" is a phrase I've heard many times, even from my own mother but it is pretty meaningless for me as I'm frequently unable to make myself do things. Even if I can for a little bit it won't last long. Even if it's things that I know need to be done or there will be bad consequences from doing them. I had to go to family court so many times for not going to school and I still couldn't make myself go.
No one would hire me anyways. There are no jobs that want to hire someone with no work history, education, driver's license or car, and doesn't like talking to strangers. I literally can't think of any places to apply except for fast food places and those wouldn't ven hire me when I was young.
Money. The ability to not be a burden on others.
If you CAN work and just CHOOSE to live off others because oh no, you couldn't possibly do something boring to earn your keep, I have no sympathy whatsoever for you.
If you can't work because of disabilities, that's different.
_________________
Music Theory 101: Cadences.
Authentic cadence: V-I
Plagal cadence: IV-I
Deceptive cadence: V- ANYTHING BUT I ! !! !
Beethoven cadence: V-I-V-I-V-V-V-I-I-I-I-I-I-I-I-I-I-I
-I-I-I-I-I-I-I-I! I! I! I I I
Um yeah, that wasn't the point of my post at all. I was responding to people who were actually saying that they didn't want to take jobs that they could take, because they wouldn't get anything out of them (except money). The word "unemployment" was not even mentioned. Nowhere was I blaming the unemployment rate on millennials. Not sure where you got that. Let me tell you right now, that you clearly have NO idea of my opinion on unemployment in this country, and how it has affected my generation. I graduated school and started looking for a full-time job in August 2008. Know what was going on then? And you think I don't know how millennials have gotten the short end of the stick in this economy? I have much more intimate knowledge of it than you do. Your interpretation of my post was completely off the mark. I wasn't addressing the issue of unemployment at all.
My post was talking about the different attitudes my generation takes towards work, versus the attitudes of older generations like the boomers. And as someone who is part of my generation, who interacts socially mainly with people of my generation, I think I have a fairly decent idea of how people my age approach a job/career versus how someone of my parents' generation (boomers) would. Everything I said about how millennials view jobs has been true in my experience both for myself and for all the many people I know of a similar age. I have no idea about Gen X.
_________________
Not all those who wander are lost... but I generally am.
Sweetleaf
Veteran
Joined: 6 Jan 2011
Age: 34
Gender: Female
Posts: 34,911
Location: Somewhere in Colorado
That is part of why people tend to dislike this generation. If the WWII generation is called the "Greatest Generation," I refer to my generation as the "Least Generation." The stereotype of us is that we are spoiled and don't know how to work. And I think in some ways that is true. This is probably the first time in history when people have had the luxury to say, "No, I won't do that job, because it's not worth my time." For all of human existence people have had to do boring, drudge tasks all day, with little leisure time, simply to survive. We are gifted with so much leisure time now, so much more than previous generations had. We don't have to card wool, spin it into thread, weave it into cloth, and then sew it into clothing. We just buy clothes. We don't have to manually scrub that clothing, or even use a mechanical wringer. We just throw it in the washing machine and go do something else. We have so much technology that saves us so much time, that we are able to spend more time on self-fulfillment than any other generation in history (and then we complain that we don't have enough time). And we view all this like it is our right- a right to spend our time how we see fit, with as little drudgery to our day as possible. But this is really all very new, very privileged thinking. Anyway, this turned into kind of a rant, but I agree with the OP that there is a generational gap here in how people think of jobs.
Disclaimer: I am not referring in any way people to people who are genuinely unable to work. Just to people who refuse to take jobs they think are beneath them because they are able to get money from the government or live off family members. Also, I'm obviously talking about 1st world countries here.
Tl;dr Work is not supposed to be fun. Millennials are spoiled and that is why no one likes us.
I think that is a good point. If there was no disability anyone who could work would do anything to not be homeless. If you don't have parents to take care of you than you do what you have to. My husband was on his own even when he lived at home. He needed a bed in high school and had to buy one himself. He worked throughout high school and paid his way through college with grants and his income. His mom had no idea he was on the spectrum and is probably on it herself. When one has to make ends meet he will unless he is actually unable. I would work a minimum wage job and share a room in a crappy area if I had to. It would motivate me to do my best and attempt to move up to a higher paying job. Getting a college degree is a great way to get ahead if it is possible. Not everyone can do this and my own kids will be have a hard time accomplishing this without a lot of assistance.
And what happens to the people who can't work due to their disability if they got rid of disability?
_________________
We won't go back.
ASPartOfMe
Veteran
Joined: 25 Aug 2013
Age: 67
Gender: Male
Posts: 35,952
Location: Long Island, New York
My father was ALWAYS worried that I wouldn't have decent work. We never had a normal conversation, and he lived to be 92... and I took care of him for his last 5 years. He was an angry man, and terribly disappointed in me. He used to tell me that I was going to be a taxi-driver. He was very anxious I wouldn't be able to take care of myself. I was sent to military school when I was 18 (he believed I needed discipline), and I ran away a few months later. I hitchhiked across the country from Virginia to Denver (this was in 1960). I got a job putting on ski bindings in a sporting goods store in a tiny back room by myself, and I also worked in a warehouse stocking western shirts. After 8 months a worker there... a manager, Hy Freeman, took me aside and told me I should go to college. A few weeks later I went home to Virginia, and got into a good University in D.C.
Fifty years ago you HAD to work. I don't know what people did who couldn't work back then. There were asylums, but I always thought they were for psychotics, and catatonic people, and the criminally insane? I don't recall ever seeing beggars back then.
I worked as a museum guard while in college, at The Phillip's Collection. I also worked in an upstairs room by myself cutting mats and mounting art for framing in an Art supply and frame shop in Georgetown. I taught art for a year at a high school, and then I got a job in the advertising department at Giant Food doing newspaper ads. That was a good job with health coverage for my small family. But I lost my job in a downturn after six years, and that was a panic. I had a series of waiting table jobs, and then we made a carrot cake, and I took it to a very popular upscale restaurant in Washington, D.C. The chef said, "I like this, but you guys never work out. Bring me six of them tomorrow." I sold him cakes for 15+ years, and ended up with 80 restaurants, and half a dozen employees.
Thats easy. back then there was lots of jobs, you know before machines took all the jobs and because of automation.
Granted i dont know other countries. But here in Denmark, pretty much the only jobs left are social jobs, as in where you have human interaction, have to work as a team, meet deadlines. Does that sound like jobs any aspergers or autism can handle?. It doesnt to me.
Now back in the old days like 20-30 years ago, so many jobs you could have, that would require zero human interaction, not to mention the pace of society is faster than ever. Back then everything was more slow, calm and relaxed.
I mean jesus even to be a garbage man here, you need a few different driving licenses. You need to actually interact with 2-3 people on the same route and you need to engage in social talks with people as well, to coordinate where garbage is picked up in apartment blocks and such.
And this is gonna get worse in the future, when 3d printing really takes hold, like computers have done. There will be no jobs anything with any manual production labour. They will be able to even print food out, as crazy as that sounds. Not to mention there is more and more people for fewer and fewer jobs each year, All those jobs that are lost to machines and such, isnt replaced by anything else.
Not to mention 20-30 years ago you didn expect everyone to be highly educated, you have to have like a minimum a university degree or phd at least. Fact of the matter is, not everyone is super smart, not to mention trouble with autism or aspergers.
For some of us, its a nightmare taking a phone call, being talked to be a random stranger, or just going shopping. To say nothing about keeping a job. and all the other things, that more important than a job, actually living for one self, not living home with mommy and daddy, because they will die, and what then ?.
Life for normal people is uphill.
Life for many aspergers / autism is up hill with a boulder.
Life for other aspergers / autism like myself is uphill with a boulder wearing rollerskates.
You can only take so many failures, before you brain and personality is permanently damaged, I know the 8 years i spend trying to work, doing nothing but work, lived at home, got up went to work, home ate, then to bed, i lost part of my self in that long nightmare. no interaction no nothing for 8 solid years. That can never be undone, and definitely hurt me more by trying, than just giving up.
Moral of the story is, sometimes its good to know your limitations and when to say stop, before you ruin more of yourself.
People on this board have thought about it.
http://www.wrongplanet.net/postt250596.html
http://www.wrongplanet.net/postt246387.html
As has been said it was not as difficult to get a job. There were just more jobs. If you did not have one you were lazy or very incapacitated. Employers were more concerned with merit then social ability for certain jobs. If you were a programmer or scientist your employer expected you to be odd. If he did not like you and you produced you stayed . You were put in a corner, given basic guidelines and that was that. A few years ago I was watching a DVD special feature for the show Mad Men set at an advertising agency in the early 1960's. In the show the lead character without notice took off to California for a couple of weeks to clear his head. What was explained in the special feature was that this behavior happened all the time in creative jobs during that era. This would not be accepted in most jobs then but in that type of work it was.
For those that could not hold a regular job your family was likely to throw you into the streets because they thought you brought shame to the family or because they believed you needed tough love. A lot of these people are dead. there stories will never be told. Others as has been mentioned were misdiagnosed and institutionalized. And those "warehouses" were big and nasty. If you needed to going to a psychiatrist or psychologist you were considered and you considered your self the ultimate failure. Especially if you were a man or were middle class or lower. You see a lot of us diagnosed in our 50's or later. That means we might have been been diagnosed 10-15 years earlier if we had gone to a shrink but we would never want to give in admit that we were a "failure".
As for our generation the attitude was we expected our first jobs to stink and to be treated like dirt. The phrase used was "paying your dues" . Then after awhile you would earn more pay, respect and perks. Problem for a lot of us is that we never got past the 'paying our dues" stage. While our peers were getting married, having a family buying a house (or getting a luxury apartment and being a bachelor playboy) we were stuck in neutral or going backward.
_________________
Professionally Identified and joined WP August 26, 2013
DSM 5: Autism Spectrum Disorder, DSM IV: Aspergers Moderate Severity
“My autism is not a superpower. It also isn’t some kind of god-forsaken, endless fountain of suffering inflicted on my family. It’s just part of who I am as a person”. - Sara Luterman
Last edited by ASPartOfMe on 07 Feb 2014, 9:19 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Money. The ability to not be a burden on others.
If you CAN work and just CHOOSE to live off others because oh no, you couldn't possibly do something boring to earn your keep, I have no sympathy whatsoever for you.
If you can't work because of disabilities, that's different.
*sigh*
You miss my point completely by not fully reading everything I've said. Actually, you're sorta also PROVING my point. You're making assumptions, which lead to incorrect info.
When I said that a job at a grocery store... or basically anywhere else.... wouldnt benefit me, I really, honestly meant it. As I stated in the very same post you quoted from, my situation is a little different. Money? Dont need it. Why? Have it already. Wealthy family, you see. I typically have enough to do whatever I want within the contexts of my main interests (gaming, and anime conventions & cosplay). If I feel like buying something, I just go buy it. Doesnt dent the funds. And I'm a total impulse buyer too, so I make purchases frequently. So yeah.... I aint short on money. That effect of having a job is meaningless in my case.
As is the bit about living off of others. That again assumes that my living where I am is some sort of burden to begin with. When it's a family with more of a normal amount of income, and with a normal sized house.... which can feel crowded easily.... then yes, this can become an issue. In my case? No. It's easy to keep out of everyone's way when I feel the need to, in this bloated whale of a house.... heck, if this place WAS feeling crowded, something would have to be very wrong. It's too damn enormous for that. And even if I was in the way, there's a second house, I could just stay there seperately if need be. So the issue of space isnt a problem whatsoever. And the money, again, not even an issue. Nobody cares about that part.
So, regardless of my reasons for not having a job..... there's no negative effect being had. Instead, there is positive effects. I have alot of free time.... I have nothing BUT free time.... so I'm able to do things like drive out towards my mom's place every day and visit with them for awhile, which keeps her from getting too depressive, and visit my grandmother many days as well, and I'm free to give rides to my friend that lives nearby if need be, and other things like that. And I'm probably going to start taking a class of some sort soon, because boredom. And learning new stuff is never a bad idea, I think. Havent fully decided what yet.
And that's just my own situation. Who knows what others may have? What their reasons may or may not be, REGARDLESS of wether they're disabled or not? This sort of thing is why it always bugs the funky hell outta me when I see someone pestering someone else with lines like "Why arent you earning your way on your own? You still live with family and you dont get a job, this means you're a loser! You have to shape up!". They dont stop to think, wait a minute, maybe this guy's situation is something that I havent thought of that changes the arguement a bit... Someone says it to me, and all I think of is "Good grief.... this AGAIN? There's no POINT in me getting a job!". All I'd do if I got a job is take up a valuable employment position that could be given to someone who DOES need the money.
I thought it was actually easy to get a job then, not because there were more jobs. Now today work places want experience and references and other stuff before they hire you and they even require some college education. People have just gotten less trusting over the years because they wouldn't want to hire a criminal or someone who will steal from them. But then that makes it harder for people like us to get a job so that is why so many of us are on disability and some of us give up looking for work because you keep trying to find a job and no one hires you and you lose hope so you give up.
Where I am now, if I was always this way my whole life, I probably would have made it in the days and live normally and have no problem and would just be seen as shy or quirky or quiet and asocial and no one would ever guess I have something wrong with me. But the way I was when I was little, I probably would have been in an institution and not be where I am now. Disabled kids were locked away and forgotten and their parents moved on living their normal lives raising their normal kids forgetting about their disabled child. That is if my parents decided to have me sent away and forget about me.
_________________
Son: Diagnosed w/anxiety and ADHD. Also academic delayed and ASD lv 1.
Daughter: NT, no diagnoses. Possibly OCD. Is very private about herself.
When we're young, the question that was asked to all of us was "what do you want to be when you grow up?" and we were supposed to say a career like a "firefighter" or "astronaut". This means that we're told from the beginning, that our being, our sense of self, will be our career. Which is extremely sad. I can't wait for the day that kids start answering that question with "When I grow up, I want to be a nice person" or "When I grow up, I want to happy". It's a genuine concern of mine that we aren't focusing on peoples happiness and well being before we focus on a career.
So true! That reminds me of this quote:
“When I was 5 years old, my mother always told me that happiness was the key to life. When I went to school, they asked me what I wanted to be when I grew up. I wrote down ‘happy’. They told me I didn’t understand the assignment, and I told them they didn’t understand life.” ― John Lennon
So true! That reminds me of this quote:
“When I was 5 years old, my mother always told me that happiness was the key to life. When I went to school, they asked me what I wanted to be when I grew up. I wrote down ‘happy’. They told me I didn’t understand the assignment, and I told them they didn’t understand life.” ― John Lennon
Love that quote! It really does sum up exactly what I was trying to say. Thanks for sharing it with me!
(Lediggang som saadan er ingenlunde Roden til alt Ondt, tværtimod, den er et sandt guddommeligt Liv, naar man ikke keder sig).
"Laziness as such is by no means the root of all evil. On the contrary, it is a truly devine life, given you´re not bored!"
(Soren Aaby Kierkegaard)
_________________
Femaline
Special Interest: Beethoven