marshall wrote:
"You can't have your cake and eat it too"
Okay, this doesn't make sense to me because in my mind the verb "have" used in conjunction with something to be consumed implies consumption. I.e. if I ask some one "want to have a beer?" I'm not asking them if they want to stand around with a beer in thier hand. It's assumed that the beer will be consumed.
Therefore the first thing that pops into my mind when I hear this phrase is "Doesn't to have cake and to eat cake mean the exact same thing? This phrase makes no sense".
Even if I interpret "to have" as "to possess", it doesn't follow that consumption relinquishes possession. If I eat the cake I still possess it, it's just in my stomach rather than on my plate. Thus the phrase still doesn't make sense to me.
i don't like that one either, but it's because i can't figure out how it's intended.
i get a picture in my head of a little girl in a party dress, maybe Alice in Wonderland, holding a piece of cake close to her, like someone might be about to snatch it away, but then i just get stuck. why can't the little girl eat her cake? i don't know. i think she probably deserves it, especially if she's already met the queen of hearts. maybe she's afraid of how it will distort her.
MathGirl wrote:
I don't understand the expression "being stood up". I eventually learned the meaning by rote, but it took a while for it to sink into my brain.
If someone could explain it to me, that would be great, because I'm really curious about its origins.
i can't take that one apart but i know how it's meant, having been stood up a number of times myself.
"pay it forward" - ?? have they left out a letter in this one? i can't make sense of it at all
the ones that trouble me are the ones that make no literal sense nor any metaphorical sense.
"straw that broke the camel's back" .. ok. drinking straw or a piece of grain? either way i can picture the poor camel collapsing like a bad move in jenga
"needle in a haystack" .. someone had to explain that one to me when i was young, but then i thought if you throw yourself into the hay you're sure to find it pretty quickly.
_________________
Now a penguin may look very strange in a living room, but a living room looks very strange to a penguin.