Should doctors who misdiagnose autism be fined?

Post Reply New Topic

Should doctors who misdiagnose autism/related challenges be fined (like fines for speeding
tickets/going through red lights)? At the moment (2010), in general, doctors are exempt from punishments for incorrect diagnoses (generalization).

I don't think they should. It could be an honest mistake, which is why the experts say to get a second opinion. If one doctor thinks so and another doesn't, perhaps a third is required? Maybe what's needed is more than one doctor diagnosing and they all agreeing on the diagnosis?

I also don't think that they should be fined, either. People make honest mistakes all the time, and that includes doctors.

If there were a 100% accurate method for diagnosing, maybe. But doctors are human. If negligence could be proven, then a fine might be in order.

No. The criteria are subjective and open to interpretation. There is nothing in the criteria that is actually measurable, the way that the speed of a car is measurable.

No. There are no simple diagnostic tests for psychiatric conditions. You could ask three different psychiatrists and come away with 3 different diagnoses, and there would be enough professional support to each opinion that it would be deemed reasonable.