Posted This On Autism Speaks Facebook Page
Dear Autism Speaks,
I am an individual on the Autistic Spectrum and I do not suffer from my Asperger's, I embrace it; my family does not suffer either, because they love me as I am.
I have a few problems with your organization, that, from others with Asperger's, Autism and family members of those with these syndromes, also find to be problems. These are only a few complaints my friends and I have come up with:
1. You have no Board of Directors members on the Autistic Spectrum. Sure, some of your members may have a child on the spectrum, but it is not the same. Unless you are on the spectrum, you have no idea how to properly help those who are on the spectrum.
2. In your mission, it says that you are working toward a cure for Autism, yet on the "What is Autism" page of your site, you say that many studies point to Autism being genetic. How are you going to cure something that is genetic? Until we have the ability to isolate the exact genes that cause Autism and edit them, there will be no way to cure it. Treatment of symptoms it possible, and for many families with a more severely affected child, they are welcome, but for most of us, there is no point in a "cure."
3. You have talked about how much money it can take to raise a child with Autism, but most of your money goes to salaries for higher-ups, advertising and research on Autism! Why not help out those families that don't have the money to raise a child on the spectrum? Many families could use the help, whether to get a suitable IEP for their child in mainstream school, or assistance in getting their child into a specialized school that will help them later in life.
4. Your ads. The ads you put out are highly offensive to those of us on the spectrum!! You say horrible things about Autism like "Autism has stolen my child," but you never go into the positives about Autism!! In no video ad have you mentioned Autistic Savants, or how Autism can bring families together, not push them apart!!
Before you go hunting for a cure, or a prevention method, or a raise for your higher-ups think about these issues.
Thank you,
Sarah
_________________
Dance like no one is watching. Sing like no one is listening. Love like you've never been hurt and live like it's heaven on Earth. -Mark Twain
If life gives you lemons, make grape juice, sit back and watch the world wonder how you did it.
SyphonFilter
Veteran
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/753b9/753b931a502ceae056516a1c01d00ba587ea90e7" alt="User avatar"
Joined: 7 Feb 2011
Gender: Non-binary
Posts: 2,161
Location: The intersection of Inkopolis’ Plaza & Square where the Turf Wars lie.
paladin
Yellow-bellied Woodpecker
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/ec420/ec42047887999cf5cf27d25787ac6e358fa133ef" alt="User avatar"
Joined: 8 Aug 2006
Age: 49
Gender: Male
Posts: 64
Location: Philadelphia PA
TenPencePiece
Veteran
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/a83b4/a83b487601f772c8e978ad91f00e174f3597f535" alt="User avatar"
Joined: 11 Dec 2009
Age: 30
Gender: Male
Posts: 46,000
Location: Greater Manchester, United Kingdom
The organization does not cater to represent those of us who have adapted to the condition and don't see our experience of autism as disability. They cater to those that see the negative aspects of autism, that want a more positive outcome, whether it is prevention, a cure, intervention, or treatment, and to create a better awarenesss of the condition for the public.
Autism Speaks exists because there are many people, mostly concerned parents, families, or friends, of Autistic people that have a more disabling condition, in the general public, that want to see the things in the Autism Speaks mission accomplished.
They are the largest organization that receives funding for Autism, but there are many other organizations that fund the same research. They provide guidelines for research, but the people that do the research seek their funding from many other sources, also.
They recently helped fund research that has led to a screening checklist for Autism in children age 1 or lower. It is seen as a breakthrough, because it allows for early intervention that may provide the child a greater chance to fulfill their potential with the condition of Autism.
There are no screening tests for Aspergers in early childhood, because Aspergers not cause the same significant developmental delays in early childhood seen in other areas of the Autism Spectrum.
However, they are funding research to try to find ways to improve the life for Adults with Autism.
The kind of input you provide to the organization has been evidenced to have an effect on the organization, because their ads are no longer as negative as they were before. However their purpose is to generate funding to assist with research in helping those that have difficulties with Autism, so it is not likely they are going to paint the condition as something inherently desirable to have. That's not unusual other organizations that fund raise for disabilities do the same thing.
Their salaries are not out of sync with other large fund raising organizations. The people with the skills to run these type of organizations are in demand and are paid what the market supports. It would be nice if people were willing to work in these type of large fundraising organizations for less money, but unfortunately as a whole that is the way it is everywhere.
A high functioning Autistic Author recently joined the organization to contribute input, so that seems to be a step in the right direction to gain focus on that area of Autism.
The general public wants the research on Autism, are willing to fund it, and would fund it through a different organization if Autism Speaks did not exist.
Here is a list of their research guidelines for 2011, for those researchers seeking funding:
Development of methods for very early detection of ASD risk.
Understanding factors that influence quality of life for adults with autism, emphasizing effective supports, interventions, and treatments, functional outcomes, medical co-morbidities, and mortality.
Identification of the molecular pathophysiology of ASD that can inform translational research for drug discovery or development of diagnostic methods.
Development and evaluation of novel treatments that can address the core symptoms and associated medical conditions throughout the lifespan .
Dissemination of empirically-validated screening, diagnostic and treatment approaches to community settings.
I don't see everything they do as good, but as a whole, so far, they are meeting the needs of those that fund them. That is why they are in existence.
Fortunately, for people that have been able to adapt to their experience of Autism, there are organizations like ASAN that provide the kind of support and focus that is needed for people that experience Autism in a different way than others may experience it.
Which only proves how lucrative fund raising is.
I'm not particularly hostile towards Autism Speaks. Its name is a bit of a misnomer since those "speaking" are not autistic. But they are doing some positive things. No organization is perfect. I would really like to see someone on the spectrum sitting on their board of directors - as a REAL member, not a token display piece.
_________________
When God made me He didn't use a mold. I'm FREEHAND baby!
The road to my hell is paved with your good intentions.
Autism Speaks exists because there are many people, mostly concerned parents, families, or friends, of Autistic people that have a more disabling condition, in the general public, that want to see the things in the Autism Speaks mission accomplished.
They are the largest organization that receives funding for Autism, but there are many other organizations that fund the same research. They provide guidelines for research, but the people that do the research seek their funding from many other sources, also.
They recently helped fund research that has led to a screening checklist for Autism in children age 1 or lower. It is seen as a breakthrough, because it allows for early intervention that may provide the child a greater chance to fulfill their potential with the condition of Autism.
There are no screening tests for Aspergers in early childhood, because Aspergers not cause the same significant developmental delays in early childhood seen in other areas of the Autism Spectrum.
However, they are funding research to try to find ways to improve the life for Adults with Autism.
The kind of input you provide to the organization has been evidenced to have an effect on the organization, because their ads are no longer as negative as they were before. However their purpose is to generate funding to assist with research in helping those that have difficulties with Autism, so it is not likely they are going to paint the condition as something inherently desirable to have. That's not unusual other organizations that fund raise for disabilities do the same thing.
Their salaries are not out of sync with other large fund raising organizations. The people with the skills to run these type of organizations are in demand and are paid what the market supports. It would be nice if people were willing to work in these type of large fundraising organizations for less money, but unfortunately as a whole that is the way it is everywhere.
A high functioning Autistic Author recently joined the organization to contribute input, so that seems to be a step in the right direction to gain focus on that area of Autism.
The general public wants the research on Autism, are willing to fund it, and would fund it through a different organization if Autism Speaks did not exist.
Here is a list of their research guidelines for 2011, for those researchers seeking funding:
Development of methods for very early detection of ASD risk.
Understanding factors that influence quality of life for adults with autism, emphasizing effective supports, interventions, and treatments, functional outcomes, medical co-morbidities, and mortality.
Identification of the molecular pathophysiology of ASD that can inform translational research for drug discovery or development of diagnostic methods.
Development and evaluation of novel treatments that can address the core symptoms and associated medical conditions throughout the lifespan .
Dissemination of empirically-validated screening, diagnostic and treatment approaches to community settings.
I don't see everything they do as good, but as a whole, so far, they are meeting the needs of those that fund them. That is why they are in existence.
Fortunately, for people that have been able to adapt to their experience of Autism, there are organizations like ASAN that provide the kind of support and focus that is needed for people that experience Autism in a different way than others may experience it.
^^^THIS^^^
READ AND RESEARCH people. Have any of you actually bothered to reveiw the research that they have funded or bothered to read their financials? Have any of you actually emailed someone respectfully from their org? Stop going off half-cocked in ridiculous public places on my behalf please..... sigh....
Like I said. They do some good work. I just think lack of an autistic voice in their leadership is a rather large oversight.
It's too bad it's so politicized.
_________________
When God made me He didn't use a mold. I'm FREEHAND baby!
The road to my hell is paved with your good intentions.
I doubt their mission of curing autism is real, but should really state that they wish to control media and public perception of autism related issues. Testing of autistic potential by US military and such, would be considerable
Cancer charities, heart charities etc etc all have similar mission statements, but in actuality very little improvement in these degenerative conditions happens. But the good folks at home know 'something is being done' (thanks government!)
In fact, the stats seem to show rising levels in disorders
Which only proves how lucrative fund raising is.
I'm not particularly hostile towards Autism Speaks. Its name is a bit of a misnomer since those "speaking" are not autistic. But they are doing some positive things. No organization is perfect. I would really like to see someone on the spectrum sitting on their board of directors - as a REAL member, not a token display piece.
I've had a hard time understanding large non-profit organizations that raise funds for worthy causes and the fact that people are paid so well, but the education,skills and experience required are the same general ones required to run any other large organization.
I can't get the idea out of my mind that people shouldn't demand the same salaries as those that run similiar size organizations that don't fundraise, but the question becomes, could they find someone to sucessfully do the job, at the level of expertise required, at a much lower salary? Maybe, but organizations have to compete for talent, and it comes at a price.
Research has led to technology that allows Autistic people to communicate their intelligence in today's world that would not have been possible when I was young. Fortunately my developmental delay in speech was not one that preventing me from speaking at a later age, in a sufficient manner to get by.
However, I still can express communication, much better with a computer, than I can verbally.
I would like to see an Autistic person on the board, that truly cannot speak, without the assistance of technology. Some of these people express intelligence, beyond expectation once they are able to find a medium for it.
However, is that a realistic expectation? I don't think it is likely that someone needing that kind of technological support to communicate would be comfortable in such a place. We all though, can thank research that has allowed them the opportunity to communicate their experience of life. The research that "Autism Speaks" helps fund provides a better opportunity for those that truly cannot speak to have the opportunity to communicate.
Maybe I am being too literal, but even if a person with Autism that could speak were on the board they would likely, still not be able to give a good account of what it is like to live with Autism without the ability to speak.
The Author that has joined the organization speaks for those of us that have adapted to the condition in the mainstream world, but he still cannot speak for everyone on the spectrum.
But, as you point out there is no perfect organization, and with the complexity of ASD's I don't think it is possible that any one organization is going to meet all the needs of individuals with ASD's.
CockneyRebel
Veteran
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/84c25/84c25e30f7078205ac97f6629ddc7bdc04831ccb" alt="User avatar"
Joined: 17 Jul 2004
Age: 50
Gender: Male
Posts: 117,579
Location: In my little Olympic World of peace and love
I respect your opinion, but there is objective evidence that the organization is helping fund research that is actually helping people with Autism.
Do the researchers; the parents, families, and friends that have loved ones with Autism, that fund the research do what they do, because they hate people with Autism, and don't want them to have a better life?
Maybe some do, but it is categorical fact that there some people's efforts related to this organization and many other organizations that are providing a better chance for autistic people to reach their full potential through the funding of research.
Just the recent development of a screening test for autistic children at age one could have and is expected to have a significant impact on these children's ability to fulfill their potential in life. The potential value of this new test to the child and family is priceless.
Why would any of us want to stop the funding for research, and take this potential away? Who would it hurt more, autistic people or the high salaried individuals that work for Autism Speaks that can find another job and carry on with their life?
It is good to see as many objective points of the issue as possible.
And all things considered, none of us can stop research that is helping people, regardless of what may come of it down the road. As long as benefits to individuals that need help are a result of the research, it will continue to be funded through some avenue, whether it is Autism Speaks or the National Institute of Health.
They can improve the organization with good ideas and constructive input, but they are not likely going to listen, with communication that expresses anger at the whole organization.
Similar Topics | |
---|---|
Ok I posted this in the adult autism but there is a myriad
in Bipolar, Tourettes, Schizophrenia, and other Psychological Conditions |
21 Feb 2025, 12:50 am |
Autism Speaks Canada Closing Down! |
23 Jan 2025, 11:15 pm |
Autism Speaks 20th anniversary benefit concert |
Yesterday, 4:21 pm |
Autistic vs Has Autism |
22 Jan 2025, 10:20 pm |