Which new Wrong Planet logo?

Post Reply New Topic

As you know, we're in the process of doing a complete redesign so I'd like to get your opinion on logos. I need to choose one by tomorrow morning so we can move forward with site design:

The first one looks more professional, in my opinion. The other two look as though they've been sketched by hand.

Of course, I appreciate they probably haven't been done by hand at all, and you probably used graphics to deliberately make them look like that, but it sort of makes them look a bit amateurish.

The first one, man!

The one at the top grabs your attention first as it's the clearest. The others look too faded to me, and the bottom one doesn't look right. I think "Wrong Planet" looks much better written on the same line.

keep in mind that we can have a stacked version of #1 if you like the stacked better.

I like #1.

.... not stacked

Straight across or stacked, I agree the clean font is the better of the two.

I like the other 'scribbley' version, but it might lend to the impression that WP is primarily a kids' site and it seems that recently, WP is attracting a sizable number of late-diagnosed adults.

Don't use the stacked one, because to me at a glance it reads Wrong Planget.

If you use the sketchy one, the sketchy theme would look better if it showed up somewhere besides just the text.

I could send you what I mean in an email if you want.

Logo #1 looks best in my opinion.

First one

I'd say the first logo (not stacked). It looks a lot more neater and professional in my opinion.

#3 but not scribbly. And keep the thickness of the font.

My vote is for the first one. I would, however, like to see its stacked version.

Also, hopefully, #1 will be 3D like the current logo?

i've added a poll to this thread (don't know why i didn't initially.

I think the one with the scratched font looks awesome, but if you're trying to aim for a more professional look, number one is your best shot.

Oh, and no stacked. Unless you're having the logo off to the side instead of on the top of the page. If the logo is going on the top of the page, then having it stacked would just waste space.