Autistic people at disadvantage?

Post Reply New Topic

Why would autistic people be at a disadvantage in societies that put high value on personal independence?

No.

Disadvantage would be on societies that place high value on social performance.

..which is basically everywhere. Go figure.

I think it would depend on how personal independence is defined (physical mobility; ability to successfully navigate resources like job fairs, stores, or navigate office politics; self-sufficiency in isolation like a rural farm). If independence is the ability to survive outside of society, then it would seem that health issues associated with autism (co-morbid) could be a disadvantage due healthcare needs; but if independence is the ability to survive and compete inside society by making unique contributions to the system, then there could be huge disadvantages associated with the need for social interactions (networking, exchanging goods or data for money, interacting with a variety of personalities, differentiating between friend or foe, etc.).

Because what society values as "personal independence" actually requires complex social negotiation. It's not really independence, it's the illusion of independence.

Some wouldn't be, and some would be. Autistic people vary in how independent we are.

Many autistic people rely on others for help to meet basic needs. For example:

Autistic people who cannot work (or cannot work enough hours/week or in competitive jobs that would give them enough money to live on) rely on others for financial assistance, or for things like food, shelter and clothing. Autistic people who can work may need help to find a job and get hired, and may also need ongoing help to keep their job.

Autistic people who have trouble with/cannot manage money may rely on others to either help them with those things (e.g. advice/guidance and reminders) or need someone else to do those things for them (a trustee).

Autistic people who cannot drive nor take transit independently may depend on others to get around. Even autistic people who are able to take pubic transit independently may be at a disadvantage -- for example, some jobs require you to be able to drive, and some places have very limited public transit service or none at all.

Autistic people who have trouble with/cannot manage all their daily life tasks independently rely on others to help them with those things -- the level of support varies a lot.

I think most/all autistic people need help at least sometimes to successfully navigate social things, and many of us need help to figure out how to communicate things or to understand others.

In a culture where personal independence is highly valued, there might be less help available to those who need it, and people may be reluctant to accomodate those who are different. Also, some people might look down on anybody who needs help or accomodations....That's my take on it anyways.

forget autism is involved, any group that is in the minority are disadvantaged as society isnt defaultly built for them or their needs, this is why minority groups get affirmative action; to put us on an equal footing with the majority groups.

exactly,theres a bottomless pit of functioning;everyone differs in independance.
the OP needs to remember they were quite recently worrying they woud be put in a carehome when their parents were to die[?], that means they cant be so confident about their own independance.

Put in a care home by the authorities or would I most likely be on the streets?

I imagine some dystopian future where 99% people work in IT. Then we could talk some advantage

Then our species, as we know it, would disappear. In order to continue our species, we have to procreate--which means, in our case, socialize.

How could a society actually value personal independence?
It's a society, the very definition of co-dependence.

The answer is: Society lies.