Cade and Jane,
Thank-you for raising these very valid points about adopting dogs and making the commitment to their care and their upbringing. You are both absolutely right about it being the owners' fault in that almost all noisy dogs I've know of are (1) always kept tied by the owner and left to howl at the sky while mostly ignored except for the daily feeding and watering and (2) most of these owners do not make the time needed to raise their 4-legged family members. I think every dog owner should be required to follow these steps if they wish to adopt dogs.
For a minor outlay of some money, a dog owner can go and take up an obedience training course for the puppy and save a lot of trouble at the personal level as well as all that acrimony from annoyed neighbors.
I have known of well-trained dogs that were just as well behaved -or sometimes better than a lot of 2-legged critters I know of. That being said, I do admire and respect the owners that do take that commitment. OTOH, there are too many dog owners who don't see it that way and it is they who shouldn't be allowed to have them.
Although there is no comparison to raising children, raising dogs is similar in some ways and the onus is on their owners for the care and training. In many of the more industrialized countries around, the Children's Aid Society (or similar body) take away the children from parents who are found to be unfit. The same should be for irresponsible dog owners.
_________________
If "manners maketh man" as someone said
Then he's the hero of the day
It takes a man to suffer ignorance and smile
Be yourself no matter what they say
**Sting, Englishman In New York