Is there a difference between NTs and us?
I have read that we have troubles seeing other people point of views, lack empathy, only want to talk about what we want to talk about and not want to hear what others want to talk about and we have narrow or special interests.
But I have seen the same with people not on the spectrum. People have had troubles seeing my point of views. My mother has even told me she and dad had to learn to see my point of view, I notice lot of people lack empathy and doctors say we lack it?
Also I have realized others certainly don't like to hear what I want to talk about so why should I hear what they want to talk about if they won't hear mine. I have noticed it with other aspies too experiencing this with none ASDs and the doctors say we're the ones who wants to talk about our own interests?
Oh and I heard none ASDs have special interests and narrow interests. Even my own brother had a special interest alright. He was into stars when he was in first grade, then it was planets, his uncles even bought him a telescope one year. Then he was into space, now it's math. He just loves it.
I have started to think maybe there is just like there is a difference between us not liking surprises vs none ASDs not liking them either. (I'm talking about bad ones like a national disaster happening or an incident occurring like your car breaking down). I was surprised how well I handled my car accident. I usually go all in panic and get anxiety while others act all calm when something unexpected happens and it's hard for me to relax and do something and enjoy it without being bothered by what happened. That must have been me making an accomplishment of how much I have improved over the past few years. Luckily my car wasn't totaled.
One of my online friends told me everyone has obsessions but with us it has to do with us getting detailed about them. I am thinking it has to do with how much we spend time with them. I do not spend so much time with my obsessions like I did when I was a kid. But I still did other things
So does anyone else think there is a difference between us and none ASDs having these symptoms? If so, in what way?
Last edited by Spokane_Girl on 25 Jul 2008, 8:00 pm, edited 1 time in total.
But I have seen the same with people not on the spectrum. People have had troubles seeing my point of views. My mother has even told me she and dad had to learn to see my point of view, I notice lot of people lack empathy and doctors say we lack it?
Also I have realized others certainly don't like to hear what I want to talk about so why should I hear what they want to talk about if they won't hear mine. I have noticed it with other aspies too experiencing this with none ASDs and the doctors say we're the ones who wants to talk about our own interests?
Oh and I heard none ASDs have special interests and narrow interests. Even my own brother had a special interest alright. He was into stars when he was in first grade, then it was planets, his uncles even bought him a telescope one year. Then he was into space, now it's math. He just loves it.
I have started to think maybe there is just like there is a difference between us not liking surprises vs none ASDs not liking them either. (I'm talking about bad ones like a national disaster happening or an incident occurring like your car breaking down). I was surprised how well I handled my car accident. I usually go all in panic and get anxiety while others act all calm when something unexpected happens and it's hard for me to relax and do something and enjoy it without being bothered by what happened. That must have been me making an accomplishment of how much I have improved over the past few years. Luckily my car wasn;t totaled.
One of my online friends told me everyone has obsessions but with us it has to do with us getting detailed about them. I am thinking it has to do with how much we spend time with them. I do not spend so much time with my obsessions like I did when I was a kid. But I still did other things
So does anyone else think there is a difference between us and none ASDs having these symptoms? If so, in what way?
Wow, I can't believe this! Me and my mom went to Turner Falls today, las cascadas, and she was telling me that I never want to hear anyone else's point of view and only want to lecture other people. She just gets quiet and doesn't respond to what I say when I get "lectury". I was reminded of that when I read your post. Too funny. That description is right on the money.
My mom is NT and if you could compare her to me you could see the clear difference between AS and a bewildered NT like my mom whom I drive crazy with the endless lecturing and inability to see her point of view...which is what others call "lack of empathy" OH! so that's what they mean by lack of empathy!
Exactamente.
I've read that the real difference between ASD and NTs is not our qualities, as our qualities are basically the same, just that NTs have more of an "even" line regarding "traits", whereas the qualities of ASD are erratic, either on the low end, or the high end. NTs don't generally like surprises, but an ASD REALLY does not like surprise, it's in the way we "deal." Maybe an NT can diffuse the situation by talking about it, whereas an ASD will keep quiet until the problem explodes.
This is just based on my personal observation and reading around btw, by no means am I an "expert."
_________________
Still grateful.
"...do you really think you're in control...?"
Diagnosis: uncertain.
An aspie once told me that everyone has aspie traits.. it's just a difference of the degree.
Also, I think it's like a lot of 'disorders' and 'conditions'.. a lot of people can have parts of them, like a lot of normal people will get depressed once in awhile, or have obsessive compulsive tendencies, but it's only considered actually clinical when it's severe enough to affect your life. So people with AS are the extreme of the lack of empathy and so on.
Spokane Girl is definitely correct. The lack of empathy thing is definitely a two way street sometimes.
I think average NTs have more of a sense of cultural conditioning for interests than I do. I can't make myself like something just because everyone else likes that particular thing. NT's are just as obsessive in their interests. It's just that their interests are usually things that fall under a category of "culturally accepted" while our interests don't and are thus considered "odd".
For example, NT's seem to obsessively like following particular sports athletes or celebrities. It seems weird to me that so many are interested in the same thing. Why is it okay for NT's to bore me with their talk of athletes and/or celebrities yet I'm not allowed to talk about what I like?
We’re only supposed to be interested in what the majority is interested in. That’s all there is to it. I say bah humbug to them. Screw em.
NTvsAS. It is like living in two different worlds. Wrong Planet is the right word for your question.
If you will, you can understand NT, and many of us do, it is our way of surviving in an quite different World for us.
But surviving is not living. You cannot live if you keep translating and copying NTs world.
I think we are some thing like a different specie as you say. (Not exactly another specie but you get the idea, more or less)
Our neuronal hardware is different to NTs.
I am collecting lots of data in my mind, I am everyday coming nearer NTs World, but I do not want to explain false ideas, when I get all ready I will tell you all together, But the least, the minimum is that we should build our own Society, or Community, as it is virtualized in WP. Something like a AS re-organization.
Why cannnot we speak OUR same language alltogether for ourselves?.....
Anyway there are thousands of AS who have not evoluted into your "awareness" or "pride", and they live behind a shield, and happily in ignorance and unknown. These are not ready for joining the "non-virtual Wrong Planet", before tjey learn some "self-understanding and self-control.
Do not forget, we are robbed of our own socialization. So we have not learnt to socialize as real ASers should. The way is natural for us, we should learn again and now, that that has been taken away from our lifes. (For AS-parents living in Nt-society is quite difficult, cannot teach as it should be in a natural AS-way. (For themselves was also difficult)
Salud
_________________
AS children we got bullyed by children. AS Adults we got bullyed by "Autism-Speaks".
Psychologist. I categorize AS vs NT. Need a diagnose? PM for an On-line Dx
t0
Veteran
![User avatar](./images/avatars/gallery/gallery/blank.gif)
Joined: 23 Mar 2008
Age: 51
Gender: Male
Posts: 726
Location: The 4 Corners of the 4th Dimension
If you step back and look at the "set of all NTs" and the "set of all AS" they really seem quite similar. Similar hopes, desires, problems, etc. Obviously not everyone is that same, but I think you could take most people with AS and find a very similar NT somewhere in the world.
NTs can't relate to all other NTs, and I seriously doubt you can relate to all AS. Some people get each other and some people don't. I see no difference between AS and NT here.
Couldn't you make the same argument for a poor person? Or someone raised in a third-world county who immigrates to an industrialized nation? They survive in a world that doesn't fit them.
I see nothing different in the WP community than the real world community. WP has had its predators, bullies, cliques, etc. What is it that you hope to accomplish by creating an AS society? There will be no utopia. We are not perfect. We do not fit together like puzzle pieces.
What language would that be? I do not see a single united language here on WP. I think you're imaging an environment where everyone agrees - and that environment does not exist.
Please explain to me the nature of the "natural AS-way." I've been in a room with 30 AS with all different obsessions and interests. There is no "socialization". It is a series of 1-way conversations with each person trying to convince the others to talk about their obsession. It's broken - and not because they were "robbed of their socialization". It's because the socialization is 1-way.
EDIT: typo
NTs can't relate to all other NTs, and I seriously doubt you can relate to all AS. Some people get each other and some people don't. I see no difference between AS and NT here.
Couldn't you make the same argument for a poor person? Or someone raised in a third-world county who immigrates to an industrialized nation? They survive in a world that doesn't fit them.
I see nothing different in the WP community than the real world community. WP has had its predators, bullies, cliques, etc. What is it that you hope to accomplish by creating an AS society? There will be no utopia. We are not perfect. We do not fit together like puzzle pieces.
What language would that be? I do not see a single united language here on WP. I think you're imaging an environment where everyone agrees - and that environment does not exist.
Please explain to me the nature of the "natural AS-way." I've been in a room with 30 AS with all different obsessions and interests. There is no "socialization". It is a series of 1-way conversations with each person trying to convince the others to talk about their obsession. It's broken - and not because they were "robbed of their socialization". It's because the socialization is 1-way.
EDIT: typo
My NT mom does not react the same way I do to new experiences and being in crowds, she doesn't sit and stare at stuff, she interacts with people, they respond to her and really like her. In other words she is accepted by everyone and generally well regarded.
I, on the other hand, do not get to share her world. I have a completely different experience, more like one shared with phantoms or shadows or something. If you could see how it is with us you would begin to understand the difference between someone who doesn't have an AS and someone who does.
Since AS is a spectrum disorder, the traits vary from individual to individual and everyone experiences greater or lesser degrees of impact in given areas of life. I notice the most impact socially and how I lecture people and cannot stop whenever I am experiencing an 'overloading' type of situation, like yesterday.
heh...heh...heh.
Oh yeah, I never got what makes sports so popular. I can understand having fun with playing sports but watching it, not so much.
Win!
_________________
I am a Star Wars Fan, Warsie here.
Masterdebating on chi-city's south side.......!
Correct, I see that IRL often
![Cool 8)](./images/smilies/icon_cool.gif)
Couldn't you make the same argument for a poor person? Or someone raised in a third-world county who immigrates to an industrialized nation? They survive in a world that doesn't fit them.
What's the point of that? I don't get where you're stabbing at with the 'same argument applies to other' statement.
Erm....Bullies? Cliques? Predators? Can you provide a link? I never saw a elitist hierarchy form here. Lots of sites don't have said hierachies either, AFAIK.
he believes Autistics can understand each other as they think similarly unlike non-autistic peple.
Well there is Amand Baggs and other peoples' discussion on an 'autistic language'; Baggs made vids on it and Grandin explained ow she learned english differently
lol....
_________________
I am a Star Wars Fan, Warsie here.
Masterdebating on chi-city's south side.......!
I think the difference is:
Being significantly impaired by the traits in ways the average society can't help with.
Unless a non-autistic will be impaired by their obsessions, routines and communication issues, they're not autistic.
After all, autism is a medical diagnosis consistent of various traits at the moment.
Maybe in the future, we'll have another 10 to 30 categories and all of us well get into one that is clearly defined by inherited genetics, spontaneous mutations, biochemical abnormalities, structural brain abnormalities and brain damage etc.
Then we might realise how much everyone's a bit autistic... or non-autistic, depending on viewpoint.
_________________
Autism + ADHD
______
The trouble with having an open mind, of course, is that people will insist on coming along and trying to put things in it. Terry Pratchett
NTs have better empathy. I don't think so. I think a lot of them don't have mind reading abilities either. I don't agree that all people with ASDs lack empathy, nor do I believe all NTs are adept at empathy. If they all were, then we might as well say none of the NTs are jerks either.
_________________
Currently Reading: Survival by Juliet E. Czerneda
http://dazed-girl.livejournal.com/
Vote Kalister 2008
Spokane Girl I have asked myself the same questions. One of the complaints I've noticed about telling NT's or others you have AS or one of the other spectrum disorders is the response a lot of times is "Oh I do that to." But when I stop and look at the whole picture then I start seeing differences.
Like NT's don't have the difficulties with social interaction. If I go to a room full of people I feel so awkward. It's like everyone else can connect but I can't. I still feel alone just as I do when I really am alone. Then there are the responses to the noises, the lights...all the sensory overload I have to deal with that noone else seems to notice or even care about. I'm thinking how can they stand this? I've learned to deal with it and come across just as normal as anyone else but it's a battle. And once I'm alone again and by myself I feel so relieved. Like "whew, I made it." To me, that's the difference between NT's and us. They don't struggle like we do and they don't have the sensory issues we do.