should i major in math or not?

Post Reply New Topic

i failed 2 exams in mathematical proofs already, does this mean that i shouldn't major in math?
i think i failed the 2nd one. math is my favourite subject and it's basically the way i think naturally. i want to major in math, but i already failed 1 math course and other courses. i get accomodations from the disability resource center in my university. i have ocd and maybe add. does the grades indicate my intelligence and math ability as being inferior?

If you are dedicated and not afraid of hard work and study you can do anything.

What are your other options to major in and are you likely to have similar problems in future with them. To be honest, you need to grab a sheet of paper and make two lists, one of pros and the other of cons.

If you have average intelligence, it means you'll need to work harder... well, if "average" means smack-dab average, you will, because most college students are in the average range, below the point where they could be called "gifted". So that means you can make up with effort and creativity what they do with raw power; you may be in the bottom half of the class where SATs are concerned, but you did get accepted, so it can't be all that bad. Heck, get yourself a tutor; that'll give you even more of an edge, if you learn at all from other people. Many higher level college students will tutor for a relatively small payment; some colleges even offer it for free.

"B" and "C" students often learn the material more thoroughly than "A" students, anyway. Many employers will hire a "B" average over an "A" average, because they know that you're more likely to get a "B" through effort, and they'd prefer someone who can put out effort to someone who can just breeze through things by cramming and memorizing.

That said: Many students do have to re-take a class. Proofs is a difficult class; it's a lot like the statics class in an engineering major--it's one of the classes that many students will fail and switch majors, or fail and re-take, and it's rather normal for an average student to do one of the two. I had to re-take physics 2, and I passed the second time around, and passed circuits (which builds on physics 2) after that. So yeah, you can fail a class, come back and learn it, and stay in your major.

So here's the question: Look back at the beginning of that proofs class--the first couple of weeks. Check that work. Can you do it now? If so, you've learned since you started the class, which means you're probably capable of completing the class. If the basic stuff from the beginning of the class is still Greek to you, you may need to switch majors. Re-taking a class isn't the end of the world, though; and you'll have a bit of a leg up on the work when you try it again, because now you won't be behind almost immediately. You'll also know "Alert! Difficult class!" and that means you can start asking your prof for help earlier, start setting aside more study time earlier, and start getting tutoring or accommodations earlier.

Okay, regarding switching majors: It's not the end of the world. If you're good with math but you have problems with the theory, I highly recommend some kind of engineering-related field... not least because that's my own field, and because nerdy people are expected in that field. Engineering is all about applying math; and once you've learned differential equations, you probably won't use anything more complex. You don't even touch tensors, and you will use a computer to brute-force a lot of the stuff that math majors figure out by hand. That said, engineering does more with visual-spatial than pure math does; so if you can't turn a shape around in your head or imagine what different forces might do to an object, you could have problems initially. (Computer and electrical engineering works on pure logic a great deal more than mechanical engineering does, though. If you're CE or EE, you're probably going to be able to get by with modest visual/spatial, if you can think abstractly and follow a train of logic.) The nice thing about switching, early on, from math to applied science is that the math classes will be required for your new major, too, so you may not add more than a semester to your anticipated graduation date.

One more thing: If you're in a difficult major like math or science, or one that requires a lot of work, like music/art or English, you're better off taking a light load. Students have passed with 12 credits and failed on 18, for no other reason than having more breathing space and study time on the lighter load.

Einstein got what in school for grades?

No, your grades only exhibit your teacher's ability to teach and your willingness to learn... Not to mention that you might have a massive major distraction going on in that specific math course completely interfering with your willingness to learn. How much of your time in that class during lectures do you spend, possibly, daydreaming?

You major in what you want to major in. It has more to do with what type of job you wish to work after you get your piece of paper that says you know what you are doing. It has nothing to do with your intelligence.

So... BAD GRADE no bearing on INTELLIGENCE and INTELLIGENCE has no bearing on SUCCESS IN COLLEGE. Need proof? Doesn't George Bush have a degree? I've had teachers with Masters in Math that even I stump with a math question.

Either way, the important thing is FINISH SCHOOL. It doesn't matter so much what you pursue as long as you don't give up and continue pursuing it. What is worse than failing a couple exams? Not getting the degree. I promise you, the exams won't be brought up in job interviews. Keep you mind on your ultimate goal. Why are you in college in the first place? Why are you majoring in math in the first place? The answers to those questions will be your ultimate goal, and just keep that in mind when making decisions about achieving it.

Also, keep in mind that if you change your major frequently, if you are on financial aid, they do require you get your degree within a limit amount of credits. They also don't like drop-out rates, even if you change a class, they consider it as unfinished. So, if you are getting student loans at all, you are best to stick with whatever decision you started with. But you can easily switch to a similar major (one that requires a lot of same classes you already completed) without too much problems.

And, I noticed someone mentioned engineering, and I hear that's a good field for Aspies. NASA employs many Aspies.

Do what makes you happy, even if you aren't a pro at it. Take me, for example. I love to draw, but I'm not as good as a lot of my peers. However, I keep trying to get better at it because it's something that makes me happy. I think it should be the same for you and math.

My sister majored in math and she told me that everyone fails at least one course. Other people here seem to know all the gory details.

I think what is most important is how important is math to you? There are very few jobs in math, even though just about everyone else uses it. (My sister worked in a high tech call centre when she graduated.) Why study it in the first place? If it is important to you, keep plugging away. If you wouldn't miss it, then go back and have another look at your core goals, and consider alternate paths.

I knew someone who knew perfectly well there were no jobs in math, but wanted to do it anyway. That's the attitude to have. It's something inside you that needs feeding.