Page 5 of 5 [ 77 posts ]  Go to page Previous  1, 2, 3, 4, 5

Yupa
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 14 May 2005
Age: 34
Gender: Male
Posts: 1,520
Location: Florida

30 May 2008, 11:08 pm

roguetech wrote:
Yupa wrote:
The teacher was punished for doing the right thing, and when people are punished for doing what they should be doing, that really pisses me off.
I think the right thing to do would have been to ask the child to go to the nurses' station (if he was being particularly disruptive that day), and speak to the parent about placing the child in a setting that could deal with whatever special needs he requires. If the socially accepted "right thing" is to ridicule and taunt children to teach them that school is a place to fear, then I don't see how Autistic behavior could be considered social unnacceptable, unless of course he was considerate to his classmates.
Quote:
In real life peoples' behaviour is evaluated when they get out of line and if their presence is determined to be detrimental to the workplace environment in any way they are fired.
Being fired would be equivalant to expelling him from the school, NOT ridiculing him and making his expulsion a public specticle. More to the point, you need to read up on the American's With Disabilities Act (for the US, other countries have similiar). "In real life" people not only may not be "fired", but are also protected against being singled out for discrimination (i.e. ridicule) for a disability. If I were treated this way at my place of employement, I would sue the socks off them. (see http://www.sunpublications.com/articles ... 822605.txt)


Once again, he was not being ridiculed "for a disability", since it was not yet proven that he had Asperger's Syndrome.
Oh, and here are some other examples of someone "being singled out for discrimination": refusing to hire a person who is proven to be mentally ret*d because you know that their disability will prevent them from contributing to the organization they are applying for, and refusing to let a cripple join a football team.
However I'd say that in this boy's case his disability should not play into the matter. If the teacher wanted him out of the class because he was playing with his pencil or because he stuttered or was twitchy, that would be different. However, he had a history of disruptive behaviour.
Another thing that should be pointed out (I know this from my experience in elementary school) is that children often want to be sent out of class, and the more manipulative students (I was one of them) will often behave as badly as possible just so that they have an excuse to leave the classroom.
Therefore sending him out of class would not be just, as it would not properly qualify as a punishment.
In fact, some students might even consider it a reward, which wouldn't exactly make very much sense.
Notice also that the articles on this matter are very unspecific about the events leading up to this, but they must have been pretty severe if the teacher had to ask the class to vote the student out.
I brought this issue up with my father, by the way, and he agreed that the teacher handled the situation appropriately, and he's usually the sort of person who'd take the child's side in cases like this.



Yupa
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 14 May 2005
Age: 34
Gender: Male
Posts: 1,520
Location: Florida

30 May 2008, 11:12 pm

srriv345 wrote:
Just a quick note of factual clarification: Examples of Alex's "disturbing behaviors" seem to include spinning, hiding under tables, and eating paper/crayons. This is from Melissa Barton, and the school district has said nothing further. There is no indication whatsoever that Alex posed a danger to others. He needs help to better deal with school, but this has nothing to do with being a "disturbance" and everything to do with ostracizing people who are different. Again, this is kindergarten, and "disturbances" are to be expected. If a teacher can't handle that, then he or she probably shouldn't be teaching at all, and definitely shouldn't be teaching kids that young. I wonder how many other kids, special needs or not, have suffered because of her intolerance.


If someone is eating mucous or licking their toes in public should you just pass them by and "respect their differences"?
I doubt it.
This has quite a lot to do with his being a disturbance.
Why aren't you more specific about why and how he was spinning (which btw does pose a danger to others), eating crayons, and hiding under tables?



Yupa
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 14 May 2005
Age: 34
Gender: Male
Posts: 1,520
Location: Florida

30 May 2008, 11:14 pm

catspurr wrote:
I was taught those so called lessons and all it did was made my hatred of people even more intense.

Maybe because a certain selfish part of you refuses to acknowledge that there was an actual purpose in those lessons aside from the sadism you seem to attribute to them?
It would do you some good to think about the actual feelings and motivations of those who taught you those lessons.



acannon
Raven
Raven

User avatar

Joined: 28 Sep 2007
Age: 36
Gender: Female
Posts: 122

30 May 2008, 11:14 pm

I've read that his disruptive behavior included spinning, picking his nose, and crawling under the table. He also seemed echolalic to me, which could be discrimination if that was a reason for his removal from the classroom. Also, younger kids generally don't want to be removed from class, especially in that manner. They tend to like school because it's a new thing to them.



acannon
Raven
Raven

User avatar

Joined: 28 Sep 2007
Age: 36
Gender: Female
Posts: 122

30 May 2008, 11:19 pm

Yupa, I'm sick of arguing with you on this. Obviously you're not getting that this child was deeply traumatized (and rightfully so) because of what this so-called teacher did to him. He's just a little boy. He doesn't have the same mental capacity that we do, because we're older. We know that spinning around can hurt people. He doesn't. Even though I created this thread, I'm going to respectfully step out of it, because you just don't seem to understand how hurtful Ms. Portillo's actions were to Alex, and, honestly, I'm tired of trying to explain it to you. Many people have tried to explain, using many different words and points of view, and you don't seem to be listening to any of them. So I am stepping out of this thread, and out of WP altogether.



Yupa
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 14 May 2005
Age: 34
Gender: Male
Posts: 1,520
Location: Florida

30 May 2008, 11:34 pm

acannon wrote:
He doesn't have the same mental capacity that we do, because we're older.

Which is exactly why he'd be less likely to experience the trauma that most of us imagine we would suffer in the situation, despite the fact that there are about a million worse things that could happen that actually would cause someone genuine trauma.



beau99
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 5 Nov 2007
Age: 38
Gender: Female
Posts: 1,406
Location: PHX

31 May 2008, 2:31 am

Yupa, why the hell are you taking the side of the stupid lowlife "teacher" for?


_________________
Agender person.

Twitter: http://twitter.com/agenderstar


Sora
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 15 Sep 2006
Gender: Female
Posts: 4,906
Location: Europe

31 May 2008, 4:31 am

Yupa wrote:
acannon wrote:
He doesn't have the same mental capacity that we do, because we're older.

Which is exactly why he'd be less likely to experience the trauma that most of us imagine we would suffer in the situation, despite the fact that there are about a million worse things that could happen that actually would cause someone genuine trauma.


Either you say that on purpose of disregarding or you're not quite informed about what a 'genuine trauma' can be, especially in a 5-year-old? Because psychs agree as well as literature agrees that this is first and foremost, a very strong trauma.

If you think different, you are entitled to your opinion, but that does not mean that it is factually correct as of today's standards and you should take that into mind.

By what you said earlier: You seem to identify too much with the child and the mention of disruptive behaviour. That is not a very good thing to do in a discussion.

Mainly because those of us who were labelled such as a child were not acting on the same impulse on intentional misbehaviour and because there are many reasons result in a teacher speaking of disruptive behaviour.


_________________
Autism + ADHD
______
The trouble with having an open mind, of course, is that people will insist on coming along and trying to put things in it. Terry Pratchett


srriv345
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 18 Jul 2006
Age: 37
Gender: Female
Posts: 523

31 May 2008, 2:13 pm

Yupa wrote:
If someone is eating mucous or licking their toes in public should you just pass them by and "respect their differences"?
I doubt it.


If that someone was a five-year old? Well, I'd try to help him reduce unsanitary behaviors, but I certainly wouldn't subject him to exile. Have you ever been in a kindergarten classroom, Yupa? It's hardly a haven of order.

Quote:
This has quite a lot to do with his being a disturbance.
Why aren't you more specific about why and how he was spinning (which btw does pose a danger to others), eating crayons, and hiding under tables?


Uh, possibly because I don't know the details of this? From my own experiences and knowledge about autism, I'd guess he was doing so because his environment is so overwhelming. Plus, spinning is fun and is usually perfectly harmless. (Many of us on the spectrum don't get as dizzy as normal people do, and spinning is quite pleasurable. I'm not saying he should be allowed to do nothing but spin, but breaks are hardly unheard of for kindergarteners.) Environmental stressors need to be addressed, but it's not a teacher's place to unilaterally have a kid "voted out." This is kindergarten, not the military.



Yupa
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 14 May 2005
Age: 34
Gender: Male
Posts: 1,520
Location: Florida

31 May 2008, 2:37 pm

srriv345 wrote:
It's hardly a haven of order.

Mine was.



beau99
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 5 Nov 2007
Age: 38
Gender: Female
Posts: 1,406
Location: PHX

31 May 2008, 4:37 pm

Yupa wrote:
srriv345 wrote:
It's hardly a haven of order.

Mine was.

I can assure you - that your's most definitely WAS NOT the norm.


_________________
Agender person.

Twitter: http://twitter.com/agenderstar


preludeman
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 21 May 2007
Age: 54
Gender: Male
Posts: 562
Location: Florida

31 May 2008, 9:20 pm

This was on CNN. I still hope the teacher is fired.


_________________
Do what you can when you can. I'm also the "alien"they are looking for.


Psycho_jimmy
Yellow-bellied Woodpecker
Yellow-bellied Woodpecker

User avatar

Joined: 4 Jan 2008
Gender: Male
Posts: 70
Location: Adelaide, Australia

06 Jun 2008, 7:18 am

Deja vu... that happened to me.