Doctoral Student with ASD needs your help
For those of you who haven't read my recent introduction, I just graduated in May with my MS in Clinical Counseling. It took about a month after graduation for everything I had learned about Autism in my program, in my internships, (and suddenly) in pop culture to sink in and (combined with a review of my life and a lot of frenzied research) caused me to realize the most astounding thing: that I have lived 48 years with undiagnosed ASD.
Now Autism is my new special interest. I have been pursuing a Ph.D. in Advanced Studies in Human Behavior for the last 9-weeks, but I am getting ready to make a change and pursue instead a Doctor of Human Services, which will teach me grant-writing skills and how to coordinate with government and private industry so I can find a way to fulfill my new dream of offering diagnosed or undiagnosed adults who suspect they have Autism or an Asperger's profile to receive a unique new form of online support services which I'd like your help in creating. I think you are going to like the concept. Here's the paper I just wrote about it for class. I am happy to accept thoughtful academic criticism, but please keep in mind, I actually wrote this considering a larger non-academic audience, because this is something that I knew I wanted to see if I could open it up to a community of like-minded peers and potentially recruit some volunteers to help me build it. I'm just looking for anyone with a passion for making a difference. Anyway, I sincerely apologize if that sounded solicitous, but I'm really not selling anything here, just looking for volunteers for an interesting adventure.
Anyway, here's the paper, I hope it sounds interesting to you:
The number of adults with undiagnosed Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD) is unknown, but if it is close to the rate of diagnosis in children, that figure could be approaching 2% (“CDC increases estimate of autism’s prevalence by 15 percent, to 1 in 59 children | Autism Speaks,” 2018). Increased awareness and the dissemination of information over the Internet are leading more adults to question the possibility that they have lived their lives with undiagnosed ASD and increasing demands for diagnostic and support services for these adults.
Unfortunately, specialists trained in diagnosing and providing support services for adults with ASD are not available in every area and can be financially beyond the reach of many potential clients. Clients may also have a variety of concerns related to trust-levels, anxiety, cultural and familial considerations and more which might prohibit them from seeking a formal diagnosis (Lewis, 2016).
Lewis reports that even self-diagnosis gives adults with suspected-ASD an increased sense of belonging through the realization that there are others like them (and opportunities to interact with those others through online forums), as well as a reported increased understanding of self (2016). Given the evidence of the co-morbidity of other psychiatric symptoms and disorders among adults with ASD (Lever & Geurts, 2016), increased self-understanding and a greater sense of belonging can be a powerful motivator towards pursuing answers for improving one’s life based on the newly discovered information of diagnosis, self- or otherwise. Indeed Lewis reports many of the self-diagnosed individuals in her study reported making autism one of their special interests in an attempt to confirm or refute their hypothetical diagnosis.
Anecdotally, as someone who recently self-diagnosed with ASD, the author can attest to the unquenchable thirst for more information and specifically for useful techniques for managing my executive function, building social skills, issues related to employment and other areas of life affected by neurodiversity. What exists is a scattering of other autistic individuals sharing things that they have learned, hacks for managing executive function or tips on how to flirt, but the level of support feels inadequate to the need of discovering that my brain works in a different way than most people’s, and it feels like the resources I might need are reserved for those with formal diagnosis, and for those who can afford specialized therapy and coaching services and/or have them available in their area. I would hazard a guess that my experience in this is not uncommon in this respect.
Ethical Considerations of Providing Services to Self-Diagnosed Individuals
As Laura Foran Lewis reminds us in another excellent article on “Identifying autism spectrum disorder in undiagnosed adults,” clients may have many reasons for not seeking a formal diagnosis, some of which (like availability of services, or financial considerations) may be out of their control. She recommends helping clients weigh the costs and benefits of getting a formal diagnosis and reminding them that a formal diagnosis is required of individuals “seeking Social Security disability benefits or employment accommodations through the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990” (2018). Other recommendations such as this could be incorporated into an informed consent form for clients lacking a formal diagnosis but seeking treatment for self-identified autism or Asperger’s profiles.
.
Providing coaching or therapy services to these self-diagnosed individuals amounts to treating the symptoms rather than the diagnosis. Many people might benefit from shared tips on how to improve the functioning of one’s executive function, prioritize tasks, build routines and habits, improve their social skills. If the course of treatment involved pharmaceuticals or other potentially dangerous treatments that would be a different matter, but providing the types of services described above as requested by self-diagnosed individuals must be ethical, and empowering self-diagnosed individuals to choose that for themselves provides an empowering boost of self-determination, which has been identified as an important factor in quality of life among individuals with autism (Kim, 2019).
Adapting Existing Technologies to Provide a New Form of Online Coaching: Proposal
A Club for the Club-less
Simply put, what I am proposing to do is to adapt existing technologies, specifically cloud-based multi-platform software designed to help business teams stay on task and achieve objectives--team collaboration software--to build multiple small (group therapy sized, or even smaller groups of 3 or four) online networks of clients receiving coaching services, including help creating to-do lists, goals, and routines utilizing the software and everything we know about best strategies for helping someone with autism, while providing and receiving peer-support and accountability through their interaction with peers’ lists and goal-setting and seeking. Some of these software solutions function like company-wide social networks which would provide opportunities for building social skills. Opportunities to engage with the larger group via a Facebook group or some other means might provide additional opportunities for collaboration, peer support, advocacy, social engagement, or creating culture. Other content (perhaps even client-generated content--e.g. particularly useful checklists or strategies for dealing with particular situations) could be delivered electronically to all members. This entity would be a membership organization, with members getting a say on important issues, and working towards common goals of raising awareness and overcoming deficits and helping others overcome their deficits.
Measurement of Sucess
Success would be measured by successful adaptation and use of the tools with guidance from peers and coaches, as well as quantitative and qualitative assessments of clients’ functioning both before signing up for services and periodically after enrolling in the program.
Additional Desired Outcomes
Through this process, if we can get enough feedback from members, we could potentially generate a list of best practices for adapting existing technologies to help individuals with autism function better in a neurotypical world. Additional technological adaptations, such as how to make the most of integrated applications like Google Assistant to create reminders, alarms, and manage one’s calendar, or maybe how to adapt technology to help make decisions or prioritize tasks might prove useful to others working with these populations.
Conclusion
It’s arguable that individuals with Autism are largely responsible for creating this alternate universe of Internet technology we live in and ironic that it is that technology and the power of it to disseminate information which seems to be driving a wave of adults who recognize in themselves symptoms of unrecognized, undiagnosed ASD. It seems only appropriate then that we adopt this technology to improve the outcomes of individuals with ASD or Asperger’s profiles by creating the support network they need and empowering them to choose those tools which work for them or create new ones as needed and share those with the community.
References
Removed because the URLs were preventing me from posting (because I am new around here), but I can provide them upon request
If you are not asleep yet, I will bore you with a few more details.
1. I'd like to use the Taskade app which is a very visual, free to use app for team collaboration. It's available in the app stores or online, and it includes lots of options for setting goals, creating checklists and task lists, and I think we could adapt it to create lots of different types of content, but I would like to invite some interested parties to the Taskade project I have created for this project, just to have a few people to bounce ideas off of and maybe collaborate with. The one thing I ask is that each person who wants to be involved with this actually uses this tool not just to collaborate about how we could adapt it, but also, first and foremost (and I say this for myself as well), to agree to use the tool to manage daily functioning in place of or in tandem with any to-do lists or other aids you might be using, that's how we are going to develop best practices.
Anyway, the app developers indicate you can have unlimited people in the group, but suggest a maximum of ten per project. I really don't want to be overwhelmed meeting a bunch of new people at once (this site is a little intimidating that way), so I guess those of use in the first group of ten will need to figure out how to structure "projects" so we can invite others to join us in smaller groups while distributing information among groups as well (Pretty sure it will work that way as it is, but I'm not really as technically savvy as I'd like to be and would love to work with someone who could complement my more right-brained nerdiness)
For the record, I have no affiliation with Taskade. They have no idea I am doing this. I have just been using the app to help manage my own executive function lately and I think it is intuitive and visual and versatile. It has an option for creating templates, and I'm working on creating templates for routines, providing step-by-step instructions and figuring out how to include time estimates for each routine and subroutine to help me take as much strain off of my executive function as possible, and to (I hope eventually) build a library of routines and subroutines that I can choose from and plan my day, like selecting them from a menu. But I'll stress, that is the way I would like to use these tools, I want to know how other people would adapt them too.
If this is something that sounds interesting to you, I would love to hear from you. Thanks for reading. Have a great day.
I think your ideas are excellent! But a couple of technical issues:
1) Don't use Facebook, which has a policy of requiring legal names. Best to have a platform that allows pseudonyms, to protect privacy. (Please note that the psychotherapy profession traditionally has privacy standards that are stricter even than HIPAA.)
2) If your target audience includes older adults, don't assume everyone wants to participate via smartphone, or is willing to use a smartphone app. So, either instead of or as an allowed alternative to Taskade, it would be far better to use a web-based platform that works well either via a smart phone or via a laptop or desktop PC. For the phone users you can perhaps also provide a simple app to facilitate login to the web-based platform.
I personally hate smartphones because (1) I'm a touch typist accustomed to working on a standard keyboard, and (2) I generally hate dealing with the tiny screen on a cell phone. I use my PC for Internet access and I use my cell phone (an old-fashioned flip phone, not a smart phone) just for talking and for almost nothing else (except receiving, but never sending, an occasional text message).
_________________
- Autistic in NYC - Resources and new ideas for the autistic adult community in the New York City metro area.
- Autistic peer-led groups (via text-based chat, currently) led or facilitated by members of the Autistic Peer Leadership Group.
- My Twitter / "X" (new as of 2021)
Last edited by Mona Pereth on 10 Sep 2019, 9:03 am, edited 1 time in total.
Can you summarise in under 100 words what you are looking for? Sorry this phone screen gives me a headache when I read the small text too long.
And, although I haven't perused all your text, what does this ap accomplish which is pen and paper does not?
Call me a dinosaur if you want!
Call me a dinosaur if you want!
Agreed. If possible, pen and paper should be an another allowed alternative to the app (in addition to a web-based platform). Maybe provide PDF files of worksheets that can be printed out.
_________________
- Autistic in NYC - Resources and new ideas for the autistic adult community in the New York City metro area.
- Autistic peer-led groups (via text-based chat, currently) led or facilitated by members of the Autistic Peer Leadership Group.
- My Twitter / "X" (new as of 2021)
1) Don't use Facebook, which has a policy of requiring legal names. Best to have a platform that allows pseudonyms, to protect privacy. (Please note that the psychotherapy profession traditionally has privacy standards that are stricter even than HIPAA.)
The Facebook group would be an optional closed group, for members who want to interact there, linked to a public Facebook page designed to help create more awareness about the project. Regarding privacy concerns, I believe it would be appropriate to advise in the informed consent that privacy is not necessarily guaranteed (no more than it is here on Wrong Planet) and individuals shouldn't use the program to share information they wish to keep private. But I don't think that would keep it from being a useful tool. As far as HIPAA is concerned, this will be designed as a self- and peer-augmented help tool, under the life-coaching umbrella, nothing that HIPAA need concern itself with.
I personally hate smartphones because (1) I'm a touch typist accustomed to working on a standard keyboard, and (2) I generally hate dealing with the tiny screen on a cell phone. I use my PC for Internet access and I use my cell phone (an old-fashioned flip phone, not a smart phone) just for talking and for almost nothing else (except receiving, but never sending, an occasional text message).
One of the key reasons I chose Taskade is that it is an omni-platform offering. They have downloads for Windows, iOS, and Linux, in addition to the smart phone apps and even a Chrome browser extension. I personally prefer to use a full sized keyboard (on a Chromebook in my case), so I completely understand that. I also understand that while my aim is to serve as many adults as possible, I know not everyone is going to embrace the technology.
And, although I haven't perused all your text, what does this ap accomplish which is pen and paper does not?
Call me a dinosaur if you want!
You are a dinosaur. That was fun, thanks.
Quick summary: I want to use collaboration software to collaborate with other adults with ASD or undiagnosed/suspected ASD in order to crowdsource the development of tools for managing daily life, executive function, etc and use small groups to promote peer-to-peer accountability and encouragement.
Pencil and paper adaptation of some of the tools we create might be an option, but it defeats the purpose of collaboration and eliminates the small support group social aspect of the project.
Again I strongly, strongly, strongly urge you to consider using a forum similar to Wrong Planet (which allows pseudonyms) rather than even a "private" Facebook group.
You never know when some really nasty person might come along and decide to dox members of a "private" Facebook group. It happens, and even we autistic people aren't all privacy-respecting angels.
Wrong Planet, by allowing use of pseudonyms, does in fact protect privacy much, much better than even a "private" Facebook group -- even though Wrong Planet itself is public. And, of course, a private, members-only forum similar to Wrong Planet would protect privacy even better.
I, for one, would really want to participate in a forum associated with your project, but only if the forum is one that officially allows pseudonyms. Thus I refuse to use Facebook, and I would feel seriously deprived if I were to participate in your project but it was using Facebook as its forum, thereby effectively excluding me from the forum.
A forum similar to Wrong Planet would also have many other advantages over a Facebook group, such as being much better organized.
If you are willing to consider using a non-Facebook forum, I should let you know that I desire this so strongly that I would even be willing to help you set it up, if you would like help with this.
Thanks! I'm glad to hear that Taskade is a multi-platform app. Please make sure participants are aware of that.
_________________
- Autistic in NYC - Resources and new ideas for the autistic adult community in the New York City metro area.
- Autistic peer-led groups (via text-based chat, currently) led or facilitated by members of the Autistic Peer Leadership Group.
- My Twitter / "X" (new as of 2021)
Here are some links to get you started on looking into providing your own forum:
- How to Start and Run a Forum Website
- 2019's "Best Forum Hosting" Services - HostingAdvice
Some info from specific providers:
- ProBoards
- How to Create a Forum for Your Website - HostGator
_________________
- Autistic in NYC - Resources and new ideas for the autistic adult community in the New York City metro area.
- Autistic peer-led groups (via text-based chat, currently) led or facilitated by members of the Autistic Peer Leadership Group.
- My Twitter / "X" (new as of 2021)
Hi franklynerdy,
I might be coming at this from a different angle. I admire your enthusiasm and thinks there is a need for what you are proposing. I had a formal aspergers diagnosis by a professional, which made my life make a lot more sense, but I appreciate that this isn’t accessible or even desirable for everyone.
You may have already had this discussion with your PhD supervisor, but I am wondering how you propose to tailor an online support service to such a diverse group of people with such different degrees of severity across the different symptom areas span the autism spectrum?
Gentleman Argentum
Veteran
Joined: 24 Aug 2019
Age: 54
Gender: Male
Posts: 829
Location: State of Euphoria
I suggest not reinventing the wheel by making a new forum on a different web site and asking people to register on web site # 1,000,001. You're at the right place already, and I don't know how you could one-up wrongplanet on anything forum-related. Maybe just ask the mod here for a sticky dedicated thread to your project in an appropriate subforum here. That way people don't have to take a chance re-registering somewhere else and you don't waste a bunch of time learning forum stuff from the ground up. You envision a complicated project already, no point adding to the work load.
_________________
My magical motto is Animus facit nobilem. I like to read fantasy and weird fiction. Just a few of my favorite online things: music, chess, and dungeon crawl stone soup.
This may or may not be adequate to the O.P.'s needs. But, in any case I do like your idea a whole lot better than a Facebook group.
_________________
- Autistic in NYC - Resources and new ideas for the autistic adult community in the New York City metro area.
- Autistic peer-led groups (via text-based chat, currently) led or facilitated by members of the Autistic Peer Leadership Group.
- My Twitter / "X" (new as of 2021)
Similar Topics | |
---|---|
Seeking Autistic Volunteers for Doctoral Dissertation Study |
30 Oct 2024, 6:46 am |
School b+ student |
15 Nov 2024, 9:32 am |
Is it worth to be "special needs student"? |
09 Oct 2024, 11:11 am |