Tadzio wrote:
Hi Relyt22,
What's the difference between "one-size-fits all" and "stardardized treatments" of the psychologies and of neurology?
You should re-read the comments you are replying to, no complaint was made about "one-size-fits all". The problem is with the "treatment". If someone said they did not approve of frequent abuse, would you respond by asking what is wrong with "happening often"?
Quote:
Is "soft-science" the same as "pseudo-science" with any practices?
No.
Quote:
Is answering canned questions better than holding onto cans?
Depends on the purpose. If my partner needs help sorting the shopping, holding cans is probably more helpful than waiting to answer a canned question. With respect to any kind of "treatment" I cannot see where holding cans would ever be useful. I can see a use for "canned questions". Take "where does it hurt?"; that seems clinically useful to me.
Quote:
It seems like using vague statistics for constructing a house of cards called the "Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders" is more dangerous, and it is spreading contagious analyzing diseases around the world, as if the world needs more disasters.
It does not seem that way to everyone obviously...I suggest that your comments are irrelevant anyway. Is Jack the Ripper someone we should all consider an ok kind of guy because Hitler really went to town? Is this some kind of "look over there, that random guy is naughty too" defense?
Quote:
The American Psychiatric Association has a very nasty habit of disparaging every group that questions its flimsy confusion between statistics and science, and the creating of a big batch of pseudo-diseases. Whether or not the NIMH spreads faster without having to worry about realities that can actually be measured, why spread it?
The DSM is one of the most "ugliest of America's cultural exports," making the works of L. Ron Hubbard look like beautiful classics.
I hope Ethan Watters' new book "Crazy Like Us: The Globalization of the American Psyche" helps to raise the question of the "atheistized" religions of Auguste Comte that has spawned into the psychologies.
Tadzio
Aha....er....well...thanks for that rather random rant....could we now return to our regular thread?