ValentineWiggin wrote:
Of course it does. There's incredible variation among human beings,
and many of us have a set point in the overweight or obese range,
all while eating healthfully and exercising.
The laws of thermodynamics are the same eveywhere. Being "obese" isn't something you are just because of your genetics; it's a lifetyle choice where you don't adapt your diet to your metabolism and activity level. Most respected doctors agree with me
Quote:
Good for you. Everyone's different. You won't find a doctor worth her salt who will tell you some people aren't healthier at higher weights.
Nothing in the article you cited refuted the fact that some people's metabolisms are far slower than others.
The vast majority of doctors will tell that you're at your healthiest within your ideal range of bodyfat. hence, the only chimpanzees who are even slightly plump are alpha males or females, as they are the ones who get to choose the food first.
Quote:
Wait.
Wasn't it you who starred in a thread a while back where you outright accused fat people who diet and exercise of lying about their habits and
erroneously claimed being overweight or obese poses inherent risks to female fertility,
to the tune of pages and pages of drivel?
Which is true. Obesity makes a woman less healthy, less fertile and also poses many risks toward the fetus if she's pregnant. I don't care what some pseudofeminists want to be the designated standard.
Fat people either exercise to little or et too much.
the obesity paradox is a phenomenon whereby 25 to 30% of obese people are as healthy as "normal" people, with no additional health risks. in some cases these obese people actually become unhealthy after weight loss supervised by a doctor. and being overweight and obese actually makes some women LESS prone to die of certain diseases (and hence live longer).
you can't simply state that "Obesity makes a woman less healthy" because it isn't true. for some women it is the case, and for others it is not.