Thanks for your reply
melissa17b wrote:
For the same reason why some humans get it in their head that being gay is not a psychopathology, but instead may be a natural part of human diversity. If you are one of the 90+ percent of people who are not gay, you might get the impression that people who are gay are mental cases of some sort, simply because their sexuality is foreign to you. A majority of that magnitude will tend to tyranically enforce its opinion on the minority, unless the minority fights back with visibility, enlightenment and the truth in their corner.
You are speaking as one of the 99.99+% of people whose genetic, genital, gonadal, and neurological (at least the gender identity part) expressions of sex are synchonised. There is a tiny minority for whom this is not true, and these various expressions of sex are misaligned. Are you saying that this is not possible? Does that mean intersexed and transsexual people are just mental cases, just because there are so few of them, or because their gender identity is foreign to you?
People who expect gay couples to have a "man" and a "woman" are misinformed and clueless, but choose to speak anyway, assuming (one has to presume) that their own experience must extend to all others. Don't look now, but you're doing the same thing.
It isn't hard to understand, just from the numbers alone, that the vast majority of gay people will not have gender identity issues - gay people outnumber intersex/transsexual people by something like 100 to 1, if not more. Against that logical background, it is obvious that people who assume that gay couples must have gender identity issues clearly haven't put a modicum of fact-based logical thought into their opinion. However, this does not preclude the existence of both gay couples with no gender identity issues and other individuals with such a mismatch.
I am not gay, but that doesn't mean that I cannot listen to gay people and understand that some people might just be different from me. As an autistic person, I'm pretty used to the idea that just about everybody is different from me. Unfortunately, this concept is still strange to quite a few people.
Thank you for calling me on that
I was just expressing my irritation that people approach me with such a question sometimes. I am actually very aware that transexual/intersexed people have gender and identity "settings" misaligned with one another. I am very empathic toward anyone who has problems with who they are inside and out and do not think for one minute that anyone with such a problem is a mental case. I guess I also take for granted the fact that I do not have problems with my gender and the relating identity.
I also think that the question "who is the man and who is the women?" refers to the roles that a woman and a man might stereotypically take up in a relationship. Such as a man doing hard labour to earn the money and the woman washing the dishes at home. I know that "who someone is" is far more deep than that. Just as with a person's gender - it is for more complex and deep than just "what role you take up in a relationship".
I guess my question "why do humans have it in their head that gender is anything more than a question of what genitals you have?" could be phrased better. Perhaps phrase it as...
"Why do some people think that gender is so simple that people just 'take up a certain role' according to what relationship they are in, what sexuality they are or what genitals they have?"
Because some people assume that if you are a gay man then you are "techincally a woman". Or that, if you are a gay man in a relationship with another man then one of you must take a "woman's role", as if women have a specific role in the first place. Or that, if you have a penis then you can only be a man.
melissa17b wrote:
audioeyes wrote:
Why do humans have it in their head that gender is anything more than a question of what genitals you have?
Answer #2 - because not all human interaction involves or is based upon sex
I don't understand how your question relates to my answer. Please could you elaborate?
_________________
RS CONCEPTIONS @ rikkimusic.webeden.co.uk