Robdemanc wrote:
I am trying to establish what readers want, and if they would find the main plot getting in the way.
I have dabbled a bit in this area. The approach I took was to first check with gay novels were bestsellers, and determine the mix of sex/romance/drama in them. If I am going for money, I figure I might do well to work toward something like that mix.
I might add, though, that if you have a strong idea for a plot line to go with it and only add erotica as it fits your natural creative story flow. Afterwards, if upon review of the work, you decide it needs more erotic undertones or sexual overtones to be commercial, I think those can be relatively easily added during the editing / revision process.
The key is to have a well-structured and engaging story line. Any needed extra erotica or sex can be added later, like icing on a cake.