pakled wrote:
wow..some serious fans out there.
Considering it's 2008, classic rock probably now includes
Red Hot chili peppers
Soundgarden
Curve
Cult
Cure
Sweet
Madness
English Beat
ok...I'll stop
Chili Peppers and Soundgarden, yeah, they prob'ly qualify by now (not to mention various other '90s rockers like Nirvana, Pearl Jam, Smashing Pumpkins, Alice In Chains, Stone Temple Pilots, Green Day, The Offspring, and maybe Foo Fighters). The Cult, to a certain extent, are classic rock ("Love Removal Machine", "Edie [Ciao Baby]", "Fire Woman", "She Sells Sanctuary", "Li'l Devil", and "Wild Flower" kinda sound like AC/DC songs IMO - then again, "Edie" sounds more like a Scorpions song and "Sanctuary" sounds almost U2-ish)
In my opinion, Curve is too obscure to qualify (though some of you guys have ALSO listed obscure bands - I would more qualify a lot of those as either "classic indie" and/or "psychedelic" - "classic rock" just has too many mainstream connotations to me). Sweet have qualified for quite some time (generally seen as 3-hit-wonders on classic rock radio - for "Ballroom Blitz", "Fox On the Run", and "Love Is Like Oxygen") - unless you meant MATTHEW Sweet
. The Cure, Madness, and The English Beat never had enough mainstream appeal to make them "classic rock" IMO. True, The Cure have a couple well-known songs (and Madness, of course, has "Our House"), but they never appealed to the same fanbase of the other "alternative" acts that are typically included in classic rock - The Police, The Pretenders, The Cars, Peter Gabriel, U2, and (if he qualifies as "alternative") David Bowie - and to a lesser extent The Clash, Talking Heads, R.E.M., INXS, The Fixx, and Elvis Costello. You could count Joan Jett and Billy Idol in the classic rock/classic alt "crossover" section as well (both of them started in punk bands), but to me their solo work is more classic rock than classic alt.