I think I prefer Branigan's version. I prefer the higher pitch, and I like what they did with the production on the beat.
Raf probably doesn't mind either way that Branigan's version became the bigger hit, since he co-wrote the song, and the royalties for it flow into his bank account as well.
Branigan's version is such a classic 80s standard, even I as a 90s kid feel nostalgic about it. "I! I live among the creatures of the night!"
Also reminds of German Sandra's hit 'Maria Magdalena'. 'I'll never be! Maria Magdalena! You're a creature of the night! Give me love! Promise me delight! Give me loooohohove!'
_________________
clarity of thought before rashness of action