piano players (about keyboards and pianos) I need advice.

Post Reply New Topic

I have been playing keyboard since I was 9, I've memorized tons of songs by watching the notes the keyboard plays itself, and from youtube tutorials, and I've written some songs. I've also performed at places around town. but I've never taken any music lessons except for playing flute a few years in school. I'm not a piano player, because I know nothing about how to play the keys on a piano since they're different than a keyboard. But I don't have a piano, and I've only played one a few times. I want to start taking piano lessons, but I need opinions on if you think I would catch on easily since I've ben playing keyboard so long and already know a lot of songs?? I also want to take lessons so I can learn to read sheet music better, because I'm terrible at that. I'm at a point in my life where I want to do something with it, and the only passion I have really is music. but I'm mostly self-taught, so I'm afraid I'll find out I'm not good enough to do music as a career. Also, I could post some videos of my playing if anyone wants to give me constructive criticism and opinions.

The layout of the keys on a piano is the same as it is on a piano; the only difference is that most of the time, a piano has more keys. Unless you have a good keyboard with weighted keys, you may find it difficult to get used to the amount of pressure you need to get a sound of a piano (although there are pianos that only require a feather-light touch). The pedals may take some getting used to if you've never used pedal attachments, but they aren't that difficult to learn, especially if you have a decent sense of phrasing. On some keyboards, the spacing of the keys is slightly different than on pianos. If you have one of those keyboards with a one-key-to-play-a-chord feature, you'll need to learn how to play fingered chords.
Apart from that, I can't think of any difficulties that would arise in switching from keyboard to piano; having played keyboard would be a huge asset when learning the piano.

Being a keyboard player will probably make most of the learning much faster. The biggest difference in technique would be the weight of the keys: you can play really soft or really hard and aggresive, slow or fast, legato or staccato, and it all sounds good. (actually the name "piano" is a short for the italian name "pianoforte", which means you can play both quiet=piano and aggresive=forte) It takes some time to get used to all that "colour" you can create in the music.

If you know the basics of the sheet-music system and can find a piano to play on as well as some simple sheet-music you can easily learn piano by yourself. But a teacher to guide you can be very good too.

If you can afford to purchase a real piano, then I would recommend that. It isn't necessary, but since you'll most likely play an acoustic piano if you do indeed become a professional musician, then you might as well start now. If buying an acoustic piano isn't an option for whatever reason (perhaps it's too loud and you want headphones), then Roland makes the best digital pianos in my opinion. They have an intelligent piano and intelligent grand series that has an astonishingly realistic action and tone (I own a Roland KR-7). If you can't afford an acoustic piano or a digital piano, your last option would be a fully weighted 88-key MIDI keyboard with the option to plug in a sustain pedal (this will be as close as possible to the real thing in terms of feel, just make sure you position it in a comfortable location).

A teacher can be a huge help, but since you're a unique student with abnormal experience, I think it's important your teacher know that you already have experience in keyboards, so that he or she doesn't waste your time. In addition to reading music, you might also emphasize to your instructor that you want to learn about music theory, and composition etc. This will certainly help you understand the music you already know, and assist you in creating your own. It also allows my brain to manipulate, store, and understand music much more efficiently and effectively.

Finally, I'm no piano expert, but I can play it reasonably well and have been playing all my life. I would be happy to watch a video of you playing and give you whatever advice I can.