I just need to say:
I think the "ask the chubby girl to work out with you in hopes she thins up enough to be hot" is a horribly, inescapably, doomed plan. Just my opinion!
I see this problem you describe in yourself with some of my average NT girlfriends. The: I need a really (super handsome, fit, rich, _____ guy). I don't think this is about AS, I think this is just something that afflicts some people. Smacks of basic self destructiveness, to me. It's also perversely the opposite side of the coin you hear so often on here: Why can't women see me for my real self? Why can't this random NT girl recognize me and notice me, and give me a chance?
I don't take exception to your ratings system. I agree with a previous poster, physical appearance is in the eye of the beholder, scientific data on male hardwiring aside. I think I am solidly attractive and I have a probably better than average figure. I have dated guys who were movie-star handsome, average looking guys, and even some offbeat looking - one guy I dated for a couple years looked like Steven Tyler, but listen - - unless you have Aerosmith singing backup behind you - that's not a good thing.
Anyway, I digress.
I have a more quirky perspective than some of my girlfriends. I don't know where it comes from, maybe my parents. Maybe my DNA. As I'm aging I realize a gift I have is looking beyond what's outside. Now, Mr. Rath is truly a conventionally handsome guy. But I can tell you - - his oddities would keep a lot of chicks at bay. When I married him, a few of my girlfriends confessed they are very jealous and want a relationship with a solid, nice handsome guy like him. "WHY can't it happen for me, I'm so lonely!". But you know what? I'm guessing many of them would NOT have dated Mr. Rath - - they wouldn't give him a chance past the awkwardness and moreover his quirkiness - not to mention the time (slow slow slow time) he takes to make the next step with everything. I will say, it comforts me to know he probably wouldn't have dated some of them either because (God love them) probably many aren't smart enough and would bore him.
ETA: I guess my rambling point is - - I agree with the person who said, give the 5 or 6 a chance and you might be surprised at what develops.