Do the majority of guys with A.S. never get a girlfriend?
WantToHaveALife
Veteran
Joined: 16 Sep 2012
Age: 36
Gender: Male
Posts: 2,174
Location: California, United States
http://divorcesupport.about.com/b/2012/ ... -women.htm
According to this article, most divorces are due to verbal abuse and/or emotional neglect ; so this latter is not just an AS problem -; wives of AS men (like those on EP) who probably didn't have husbands before would mistakenly think this emotional neglect is an exclusive AS trait - it is not, it's simply a heterosexual-interaction problem, it is simply a common man trait: If you read brain differences studies between men and women, vs between NTs and ASs, you'll see that the brain differences between men and women are far greater and way more obvious than the brain difference between AS and NTs of the same gender.
The brain differences of NTs vs ASs are still blur and can only be seen in some curvature and in wiring through MRI scans, while the differences between the genders are as deep as the very physical composition of the whole brain (White:Grey), let alone the wiring.
I believe the failure rate of relationships are high due to these significant brain differences.
Do you mean the theory that women are more emotional while men are more logical? Yeah, you're not really helping your argument by bringing that up Boo. First of all, I'm not sure how accurate it is as women can be logical and men most definitely do have emotions. Secondly, have you ever thought that even if that was true, that being an aspie or otherwise on the autism would actually increase and exacerbate the problem? Look up E-S theory, it's a theory by Simon-Baron Cohen that people on the autism spectrum in general have a systemising, rather than empathising cognitive style, which according to what you've said above is associated more with men. In fact, Baron-Cohen had initially even referred to the aspie brain as the "extreme male brain":
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Empathizing?systemizing_theory
Baron-Cohen also states that aspies have less empathy than psychopaths and are practically in internal threat to any company that employs them. I can't take anything he says seriously.
No he doesn't say that at all. He corrected his book (if that's what you're referring to) to say that we do have emotional empathy. Nor do I think that he's ever said that we're an internal threat to companies that give us jobs and employment, in fact, he promotes the idea of employers making accommodations for people on the autistic spectrum as they would for any employee who's disabled.
But my past has been insanely difficult for initiating relationships with women.
I don't get why it had to be so tough, feels like hell to me.
Even now that I'm married, when I walk around in public, people look straight through me like I didn't exist. I'm incredibly lucky I'm married.
I didn't ask for this curse, it really makes me sad when I think about how tough it has been to connect with people during my life. Some times it has worked out, and people would do activities with me.
Other times, it seemed like people were avoiding me. Makes me crazy when I think about it.
I wouldn't wish autism on anyone, it has been way too difficult. I just want to be LIKED and LOVED. My wife provides these two critical needs for me, and I'm very happy with her. I feel the rest of the public is SO COLD towards me.
Makes me want to move out of the state it feels so isolating.
Ok rant done. *sigh*
The_Face_of_Boo
Veteran
Joined: 16 Jun 2010
Age: 42
Gender: Non-binary
Posts: 33,044
Location: Beirut, Lebanon.
No Jono, all I am saying that women and men differ significantly in brain composition, they process thoughts, logic and and emotional stuff differently and the differences are greater than NT/AS of the same gender, It's a matter of difference rather than more and less.
I would imagine if a genderless aliens get their hands of a brain of each gender they may theorize they belong to two very close species.
I would imagine if a genderless aliens get their hands of a brain of each gender they may theorize they belong to two very close species.
Claims about anatomical/functional differences in the brain tend to get over-exaggerated. There's been several studies showing big differences that have not had the same results when duplicated. However, there does seem to be general, small differences, though it wouldn't be too unusual to find a guy with a brain that looks closer to the stereotypical gal brain and vice versa (thus, how accurate of a stereotype is it?). Also, the jury's still out as to whether this difference is due to how one is raised or whether it's biologically "predetermined" to be that way. Studies have shown that experience can significantly affect brain development, so we really don't know at this point. Maybe the world would be vastly different if as a culture, we had similar expectations from males and females, men and women.
You always carefully choose words to paint an ugly picture of AS guys here.
You just now noticed this?
But i'm wondering if a lot of those guys with Asperger Syndrome are using it as a crutch, as an excuse, they use it as a way to bring them down and not believe it is possible for them to get a girlfriend, as to that is the main reason as to why they would still be single well into their 30's and even 40's and beyond, me personally i'm 26 and I still haven't had a girlfriend yet, it is very depressing for me, I don't want to feel it is hopeless.
I have Asperger's (diagnosed) and right now, I am engaged to the love of my life who I've dated for over a year. Before that I have had several girlfriends. Just because you are autistic does not mean you will be 'forever alone', that's nonsense. Sure plenty of men and women on the spectrum have more trouble forming (or keeping) romantic relationships, but this is not a general theme for all. And no matter how severe your situation, how debilitating your circumstances, there's always still hope that you can find someone understanding, kind and caring. Or someone who simply doesn't have a clue! My fiancée for example doesn't even know I have AS, it never occurred to her something was "off" with me. Not everyone has as much trouble with eye contact or uncontrollable movements. If you have a decent sense of humor, enough to break the proverbial ice, conversation isn't all that difficult. Socialization can be learned, social interaction, friendship. It may be harder then for your average NT, but there's plenty of NT people who have as much or even more romantic issues then us.
Ultimately it depends on the individual. No two individuals are entirely the same, whether they be on the spectrum or not. Keep that in mind. There's always hope, and there is someone for everybody. Yes I know it sounds cliche but you have to keep the hope alive or you'll never get anywhere. Stay positive and optimistic and hope for the best, knowing that many others on the spectrum have been where you are now and ended up being successful eventually!
I'm married to one of those 'wife-diagnosed' aspies. I feel pretty firm in my conclusion. Others have suggested it to me as well.
I have tried very hard to make my marriage work. But the 'brutal honesty' thing eats away at me, the sensitivity issues and the 'routine' thing makes things very difficult. The meltdowns and even the mini-meltdowns (outrageous tantrum, but seems to blow over very quickly) are hurtful and stressful to me. They are frightening. Even when he's in one of his 'nice' phases, his behaviour is pretty hard to handle.
To imply that I'm not empathetic to his needs is really pretty far from the truth. I've been plenty empathetic. But there comes a time when I need to protect myself (and alas my son) from his behaviours. I also long for a relationship which can provide ME with emotional support on a more predictable basis. I'm tired of walking on eggshells.
It's not just his aspergers behaviour, some of his bad behaviour is stuff he chooses to do, but there's always a filter of aspergers over those behaviours which make them feel worse. He seems consitutionally unable to apologise. Today he broke one of my favourite things through clumsiness and he didn't say sorry. Didn't say a word. This is one where a sorry is a no-brainer. This is by far not the only instance of failing to apologise for stuff but instead often going off into a diatribe about how something isn't his fault or why he shouldn't have to apologise.
Where AS/NT relationships seem to work is where the AS partner understands some of the impact of his/her behaviour and at least tries to acknowledge it or work around it. I can't recall one instance of these self-help forums where NT partners haven't listed a huge number of compromises and work-arounds and catering to the AS spouse. We just want a little reciprocity.
That doesn't mean that he actually has Asperger's. I take it that you're not psychiatrist, so how do you actually know.
What have you tried? Also, when does he have these meltdowns and why?
It may be your perception that you've been empathetic to his needs but that depends. What is your perception of what his needs are? Let me guess, the behaviours that you're wanting to protect yourself from are his so-called meltdowns right?
Also, regarding emotional support, have you ever tried telling him when you need emotional support and what for? If you haven't then as someone who may have difficulty picking up social cues, he cannot read your mind. This is part of the reason why I've said that people haven't been empathetic, him giving you emotional support might in some instances also be something that you have to help him with.
Most aspires eventually learn to apologise for things even they happen by accident. If doesn't do that then that's a problem. When he's calm, I'd suggest telling him afterwards that he needs to apologise for things even if they're a mistake or that he needs to be more careful. It seems to me that he's not taking responsibility for things if he's negligent or reckless.
I can at least think of one such forum, where most people seem not to have done much at all. The members of ASPartners in Delphi forums seem to do very little, have no empathy, and then on top of it rant and rave about how terrible their AS partner is. The AS partner can't reciprocate if they don't understand what's expected of them, so that's part of what you need to help them understand.
I have tried very hard to make my marriage work. But the 'brutal honesty' thing eats away at me, the sensitivity issues and the 'routine' thing makes things very difficult. The meltdowns and even the mini-meltdowns (outrageous tantrum, but seems to blow over very quickly) are hurtful and stressful to me. They are frightening. Even when he's in one of his 'nice' phases, his behaviour is pretty hard to handle.
To imply that I'm not empathetic to his needs is really pretty far from the truth. I've been plenty empathetic. But there comes a time when I need to protect myself (and alas my son) from his behaviours. I also long for a relationship which can provide ME with emotional support on a more predictable basis. I'm tired of walking on eggshells.
It's not just his aspergers behaviour, some of his bad behaviour is stuff he chooses to do, but there's always a filter of aspergers over those behaviours which make them feel worse. He seems consitutionally unable to apologise. Today he broke one of my favourite things through clumsiness and he didn't say sorry. Didn't say a word. This is one where a sorry is a no-brainer. This is by far not the only instance of failing to apologise for stuff but instead often going off into a diatribe about how something isn't his fault or why he shouldn't have to apologise.
Where AS/NT relationships seem to work is where the AS partner understands some of the impact of his/her behaviour and at least tries to acknowledge it or work around it. I can't recall one instance of these self-help forums where NT partners haven't listed a huge number of compromises and work-arounds and catering to the AS spouse. We just want a little reciprocity.
it is possible to both be on the spectrum and also not be a very nice or considerate person at the same time--it is also possible for a person who is not very nice and also diagnosed with an ASD to use that diagnosis to justify not being very nice to people. it's not the autism that is prompting them to do that, it is the not-niceness of their personality prompting them to justify their intentionally bad behaviour. we on the spectrum may not always have the foresight to avoid making certain social mistakes and faux-pas, but we are certainly capable of apologising once we've realised (or someone has informed us if we don't realise ourselves) that we've made a mistake or unintentionally hurt someone or been rude. if he's been informed that he's made an error and refuses to apologise for the oversight, then that's not ASD, that's just him being kind of immature and a jerk. unless he is severely intellectually incapacitated by his autism he is capable of learning to apologise when he's made an error--unless that is, of course, that he doesn't want to apologise. if it's a matter of not wanting to apologise, then autism is not the issue--douchery is the issue. but if he's willing to be honest with himself and work with you, that is something that can change.
have you tried marriage/family counselling?
I have tried very hard to make my marriage work. But the 'brutal honesty' thing eats away at me, the sensitivity issues and the 'routine' thing makes things very difficult. The meltdowns and even the mini-meltdowns (outrageous tantrum, but seems to blow over very quickly) are hurtful and stressful to me. They are frightening. Even when he's in one of his 'nice' phases, his behaviour is pretty hard to handle.
To imply that I'm not empathetic to his needs is really pretty far from the truth. I've been plenty empathetic. But there comes a time when I need to protect myself (and alas my son) from his behaviours. I also long for a relationship which can provide ME with emotional support on a more predictable basis. I'm tired of walking on eggshells.
It's not just his aspergers behaviour, some of his bad behaviour is stuff he chooses to do, but there's always a filter of aspergers over those behaviours which make them feel worse. He seems consitutionally unable to apologise. Today he broke one of my favourite things through clumsiness and he didn't say sorry. Didn't say a word. This is one where a sorry is a no-brainer. This is by far not the only instance of failing to apologise for stuff but instead often going off into a diatribe about how something isn't his fault or why he shouldn't have to apologise.
Where AS/NT relationships seem to work is where the AS partner understands some of the impact of his/her behaviour and at least tries to acknowledge it or work around it. I can't recall one instance of these self-help forums where NT partners haven't listed a huge number of compromises and work-arounds and catering to the AS spouse. We just want a little reciprocity.
it is possible to both be on the spectrum and also not be a very nice or considerate person at the same time--it is also possible for a person who is not very nice and also diagnosed with an ASD to use that diagnosis to justify not being very nice to people. it's not the autism that is prompting them to do that, it is the not-niceness of their personality prompting them to justify their intentionally bad behaviour. we on the spectrum may not always have the foresight to avoid making certain social mistakes and faux-pas, but we are certainly capable of apologising once we've realised (or someone has informed us if we don't realise ourselves) that we've made a mistake or unintentionally hurt someone or been rude. if he's been informed that he's made an error and refuses to apologise for the oversight, then that's not ASD, that's just him being kind of immature and a jerk. unless he is severely intellectually incapacitated by his autism he is capable of learning to apologise when he's made an error--unless that is, of course, that he doesn't want to apologise. if it's a matter of not wanting to apologise, then autism is not the issue--douchery is the issue. but if he's willing to be honest with himself and work with you, that is something that can change.
have you tried marriage/family counselling?
That's kind of what I had said about that particular point. Not apologising after making a mistake is not really an AS issue. You must be careful about attributing all bad behaviour to AS.
The_Face_of_Boo
Veteran
Joined: 16 Jun 2010
Age: 42
Gender: Non-binary
Posts: 33,044
Location: Beirut, Lebanon.
You guys need to be persistent and confident, it only take a one girl to bring you happiness.
I get the hunch that this is a main factor in answering the original question. We like methods and routine to what we do, and romance buds a little more spontaneously, often requires good reading of one another's intentions to pull off, but at least it can come from almost any situation on some occasion, and not just in a loud bar while under the influence. The uninitiated straight aspergic man often has to wait for the odd chance of being directly asked out, being paired off by a friend, or even having her wrap her arms around him and pull him down before he realises he likes what's happening. But if he pulls it off once he's much more in the know on how it might work for the future.
As for half this thread devolving into maintaining relationships and marriages, meh. As far as I see it these things always needs work, and even if the eros vanishes the overriding, super-strong friendship bond should remain as a foundation.
Oh and tarantella, this one's for you. I think that a lot of the time when NT's seem to be doing a lot of work on their relationship with the AS partner and it doesn't seem to help, it's mostly because they actually lack an understanding of the disorder. There are a number of books on this topic that include suggesting ways of getting around this misinterpretation problem that you keep alluding to when communicating. Fore example, there's this one that's actually been written by someone with a PhD in psychology:
http://www.amazon.com/dp/1608820777/ref=rdr_ext_sb_ti_sims_8
Here's a good one that's written by woman who actually managed to get her NT/AS relationship to work despite running into absolutely all the issues that you've mentioned:
http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/1843107341/wrongplanet-20?creative=125581&camp=2321&link_code=as1
There are a few other's like Jerry Newport's book, which he wrote about his relationship with his wife and both of them have AS. Some people seem to like Maxine Aston's book "The Other Half of Asperger's" but some don't because they feel that it actually put's down people with AS.
The problem with asking male aspies to remain persistent and confident is that the nature of the amount of rejections we often have to go through to learn 'how it works' is actually detrimental to confidence-building, a human can only take so much failure before their self-esteem evaporates, aspies are not unfeeling robots, each rejections always hurts like hell.
I mean I still remember the faces of each and every rejection I received... and in fact, it hurts me so much now that I tend to avoid women with those similar characteristics in a true PTSD manner... This is the sort of upwards climb a lot of us have to face, and with each rejection the hill gets steeper and steeper, and then people will blame me for feeling emotions, for being disappointed in all my failures.
Believe me, if I could put my hand in that 'fire' and not feel anything, I would do it, but because I'm human, that means the fire is going to hurt like hell, worse yet is that my conditions means that the fire will burn me much more often than otherwise.
This is probably the sort of pitfall that tons of male aspies fall into, myself included. One that's nearly impossible to climb out of without a sheer amount of luck, or without a tremendous support system of friends and family.
OK y'all
OF COURSE I've tried seeking outside help.
No, I'm not a psychologist, but I am well educated with degrees in physical and social science and a career's worth of experience of social research and diagnosing cultural and behavioural issues inside organisations. I'm capable of reading diagnostic criteria and matching these to the behaviours and characteristics of someone I've lived with for most of my adult life. So while I acknowledge that this isn't an official diagnosis and only an educated hunch - I feel pretty confident.
Since this dawning realisation, I have researched and read about and tried to implement ways of improving relationships between AS/NT partners. But I am exhausted from doing ALL the work in this area and worn down from the criticism, the meltdowns and the over-prioritisation of special interests. I have a responsibility to myself to address and fulfil my own needs.
OF COURSE not all of his behaviours are Aspergers caused (assuming you grant me for a moment that I may be right). But if Aspergers is part of who you are then at the very least it's a confounding factor. And certainly I believe it to be more than that.
Jono you talk about meltdowns as if they are some kind of meaningless symptom of the condition. But in fact they are damaging and hurtful and abusive. You may think the intention means they are not abusive but abuse is defined by behaviour and impact and not intent. Many NT abusers feel out-of-control when they abuse, but that doesn't make it not abuse. Yes, I can see what influences the onset of metldowns, certain stressors and in particular auditory stimuli - but a lot of these are outside of MY control, yet I bear the brunt of the results. His behaviour is HIS responsibility. I have spent much of my marriage tip-toeing around him and trying to make sure not to upset him. But sometimes life means that he's upset by something else or I need him to fulfil something in his role of father/husband/family member.
And the thing about emotional support...sometimes when you need it most are the times that you are least able to articulate it. But I have tried doing so...dispassionately on many occasions. I have asked for specific and concrete and quite reasonable behaviour changes only to be met by excuses or outrage. I've tried writing it down. I've tried going through a therapist.
For individuals on the spectrum, you can continue to deny that asperger tendencies are damaging to relationships or you can work on your own or with your partner to moderate those behaviours. No one is saying that ALL the work should be on the AS side. No one who goes into a relationship should think that all the work and compromise should be one-sided. But that's what many of us who have married AS partners have found expected of us.
Similar Topics | |
---|---|
John Thune new Senate Majority leader |
13 Nov 2024, 4:12 pm |
Are ruthless guys more attractive than kind, good guys? |
17 Nov 2024, 8:07 am |
Advice regarding girlfriend |
30 Oct 2024, 8:33 am |
My brother attracted to his mates girlfriend |
04 Oct 2024, 7:13 pm |