It's impossible to not be creepy at least once in a while.
If you try to be social with women, eventually you're going to make a mistake, or they'll perceive it as a social faux pas, depending on their mood or who you remind them of. Even if you're just being friendly, they might not believe it.
If you're only partially social with women, you can still slip up once in a while and come across as awkward. Well hell, men are only human. Also, you can be the funniest guy on the planet- if you're not attractive and they think you like them, you're screwed.
If you're never social, then you'll get labeled mysterious, or disaffected, (who are we kidding, "creepy") and you wonder what the hell you did to deserve such hostility. If you try to prove people wrong, you already have strikes against you, so any attempt to change their mind could backfire. So you go back to minding your own business, which is creepy.
So......... it's a numbers game. Easy come, easy go. And if somebody eventually thinks your creepy, who gives a ****. Take it in stride and move on.