It'd be irrelevant either way. I'll have little in common with either of them. I kinda shy away from shy girls, as I have enough social difficulties of my own, and I can't take on her social difficulties too, and do all the work of socializing for her. So in that sense, I'd prefer a more "NT" girl, but I've found out, outgoingness has little to do with AS or lack of it, at least that's the way it works out for me.
Now a girl who is obsessed with old 80s Japanese pop and italodisco, that'd be great. And if she could cook...