Men Want to Fix Things but Women Don't?

Post Reply New Topic

If your girlfriend tells you her car broke down, that is TWO problems. One, her car needs repairs. Two, she's unhappy. The desired outcome is that you fix both of these problems.

I would want to solve both those problems---but I wouldn't want to be taken for granted in the process.

Or she could take the car to a professional, like everybody does. I am not a mechanic.

in my own experience with men as a woman, they have most often been eager to come to a resting conclusion to the issue even if doing so allows the reasons why the issue became an argument to be left undiscussed. I think that it fixes the issue in the short term but doesn't provide a long term solution. I can only speak for my own experience regarding men and women, but in regards to what it means to fix something, I think that short term results inevitably lead to a future failure of the same system.

If aliens of an asexual species who have no understanding of gender/sex/family in their world invade us, capture us, observe our daily behaviors in captivity housing, scan our brains for wiring analysis and then autopsy them (the brains) for organic analysis, then they might end up thinking that men and women are two very closely related species but not entirely the same one.

I don't think humans are conditioned to generalize. I've seen people recognize patterns at incredibly young ages without intervention by parents or others. Yes though, you cannot ever possibly say something is 100% something all the time, but for the sake of simplicity and getting things done, that's usually what people are most interested in. Socially I think it depends on context but I've seen generalization be used with outliers, usually as warnings. For instance:

If you're driving and hear sirens, pull over immediately. Though sometimes you'll only want to when you're in a safe spot to do so.

Terrible analogy, I know, but I think it works. If you overwhelm people with a "remember all these locations in the world where you'll have to delay pulling over" in a stressful situation like driving I think less people would drive.

I can only account for women I've dated and they're usually fiercely independent, though I do hang out with women that could be considered 'not independent', and those types of women can be quite different. The women I date are weird with physical intimacy, sometimes they're in the mood for a hug but usually physical contact is kept to a minimum. ie, we don't hold hands, we only hug when saying goodbye etc. and they never ever want to talk about problems (either just to talk or what I want to do which is fix) but it obviously affects them. I was pretty much raised by just my mom for a long time and she has a hard time with logical steps (she absolutely hates math) but somehow I bring out solutions based on logic. In terms of other vectors I was usually a loner, and didn't pay much attention in class (looking back I was surrounded by women growing up; interesting). Outside during recess though I'd always see the kids just form into their groups intuitively, it was weird. Long story short, in my observations I've seen more intuition and presumption based on generations of advice (like buying a girl a doll even though she could grow up to hate them) than hard wire social brainwashing. Like if you ask kids "raise your hands if you want to be a nurse" the boys usually won't and some girls will; If you ask their parents they respond with either an "I don't know" or something entirely different.

Maybe I'm consistently dating weird women, I'm not sure. That sample size is too small to say, and it is just my observations so I don't know.

Whatever. I'm not the stereotypical male. I don't just try to "fix" things. I value empathy. At least towards people who are decent human beings.

Also, it's possible to validate a person and look for practical solutions at the same time in most cases. It isn't one or the other.

Humans are hardwired and conditioned to generalize.

^
That's actually correct. It was a bit of a knee jerk reaction on my part earlier, as it seemed to imply "hey, I'm conditioned to generalise, so you can't blame me for thinking all women are b*****s and all men are pigs, because I've met a few who are". Probably read to much into it, although plenty of people follow such train of thinking without even realising it.

What I actually meant was that people who rely solely on generalisations and the simplistic binary thinking they have been taught in school, are doing themselves a great disservice. Their understanding of the world and people will unavoidably be very fragmentary and superficial and their own preconceived ideas and expectations will work against them when trying to establish a connection with others.

A philosopher once said "the exception does not confirm the rule, but creates a new one". If you have an odd foot, you look for the odd shoe, the normal ones will hurt your feet and drive you crazy. This is what seems to happen to a lot of people here who try to date or befriend "normal" people.