Guys - who would you choose?

Post Reply New Topic

Girl A

Girl A is 20 and lives in a large city where she attends a famous university. She's reading chemistry and has good career prospects in her chosen field. She is considered smart and attractive with a healthy figure, to the point of model-like attractiveness, and has long, wavy red hair (looks very Irish). She dresses up a lot in a cute shirt and jeans or maybe a professional blouse and skirt; whatever she wears, she models herself after Kim Kardashian and Jennifer Lopez. Hobbies include going out to bars and clubs in university circles, travelling and going to concerts and shows.

She is heterosexual. Very social and has a wide social circle. Because of her life and background, she has high standards, and would be judgmental and disdainful, even harsh, to guys who aren't attractive looks-wise or socially, even towards guys who are average. She has quite a sarcastic sense of humour too and is morally liberal. Notwithstanding that, politically she is a committed Republican (or other conservative party).

Girl B

Girl B is 20 and lives in a remote, rural small town in the midwest/south US or somewhere similar. She is shy and quiet, but not extremely so. She failed at getting into college so has remained in the area where she grew up. There, she works as a carer at a nursing home in a nearby town where she isn't so popular among the staff. This is because she is obese, and also has OCD and low self esteem. So far, she has made one suicide attempt.

She is a committed Christian, is morally conservative and a Republican (or other conservative party) voter. She is not judgmental of people, wherever they may be deemed to be on the social ladder, more or less treating people as equals. She has a pleasant personality. She dresses plainly and rather unfashionably. She's been known to 'friend zone' guys by saying she's a lesbian when she's aware she's really bi. She does try to suppress her bisexuality because of her conservative environment. But her social situation should make her easy to get a date with.

Any other questions about Girl A or B, please don't hesitate to ask.

To understand the question correctly - both of these girls have made themselves available to you and your only job is to pick one like merchandise off the shelf?

Are these people you know? And you're asking us to decide for you?

Of course they're not people he knows - look at the other threads in this forum, it's just a hypothetical situation

Anyway, I'd choose Girl A, despite her being a republican lol. I'd be surprised she was interested though, given that it says she's very critical when it comes to looks.

I think I've gotten to the point where I am not going to be dating too many 20 year olds, but hypothetically most people in the real world are going to chose A, since she has the more desirable characteristics and it sounds like you would more fun with her. I do like shy girls though, so who knows. B would probably be someone I would befriend and have the possibility of developing something more later as we got to know each other, while A would be someone that I would date over the short term before we would most likely move on to the next person.

Ah. I didn't understand that this is some sort of hypothetical game. I don't understand it's purpose.

Neither.

Probably neither. Girl B sounds like she has a lot of issues to work out and obviously isn't really in the market for a relationship with anyone. I would be OK with Girl A unless I wasn't good enough for her.

Blimey, this is almost as much work as real dating. Can we have bullet points next time?

Oh definitely #1. I wouldn't have any expectations and when it didn't work out she'd be just fine with it too. It would probably be wicked fun while it lasted.

They both sound annoying, I choose option C, self service.

I wish these threads would make a suicide attempt. A successful one.

Ok, but Bazooka number one has a nice body, likes creme brulee but only shoots nerf missiles full of snot. Bazooka number two is ugly, hates the smell of fresh baked bread but shoots rockets with a frag range of 30 feet, nothing but pink mist. Which do you choose?