Maxine Aston's new book

Post Reply New Topic

I've found out about this new book by Maxine Aston called "What Men with Asperger Syndrome Want to Know about Women, Dating and Relationships". I know that it's written by Maxine Aston and I've critical of her in the past but this one seems to be written specifically for men on the spectrum and gives tips on how to find a partner as well as how to maintain the relationship later on. Has anyone read it and what do you think of it? Also, why is it only for men? Shouldn't there be a similar one for female aspies?

http://www.amazon.com/Asperger-Syndrome-about-Dating-Relationships/dp/1849052697/ref=la_B001JP7THM_1_4?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1420403749&sr=1-4

From Look Inside p61:

"The rule in attraction is that you always need to stay at the rating as yourself and try not to go up or down more than one level. This information is very useful if the man is exploring dating sites or is considering someone he has met at work or in an interest group. So if a man rates himself at 7 he should be looking for a prospective partner who would be rated at between 6 and 8".

Oh dear. Oh dear. Oh dear. If I wanted complete rubbish made up by teenagers I'd ask a particularly daft teenager. It's extremely worrying that someone who actually gets people to pay her for relationship counselling is coming out with lines like that, I'm pretty sure some poor quality AI fed by trashy women's mags could do better.

Also for me (although I'm not a man), a partner who shares an interest, preferably a special interest, is an absolute essential thing. I would be surprised if that was unusual, but she doesn't appear to mention it. If I did the traditional dating thing, anyone put off by me talking about my special interests on the first date would be dead loss anyway so it's not a no-go topic at all! Likewise politics and religion, if you're offended by my views, a relationship would never work, I am opinionated and close companions need to be people who I can b***h about things like that with.

There isn't one for female aspies because writing about female aspies doesn't give her an outlet for misandry.

You can see more pages if you're logged into Amazon, it gives a selection through most of the book then.

I've read Asperger's in Love which indicates she doesn't have the foggiest idea of the value of shared special interests in a relationship. She is vaguely aware that Aspies can have unusual interests, but that chapter makes it quite clear she believes the fallacy that you can easily choose new ones on the grounds of what the local paper indicates might be a good way of meeting women. The only mention I've seen of special interests rather than just casually trying things out in that preview is a risk of putting people off, not a vital thing you need someone interested in, or a big part of your life.

It also has in the cons that it might be expensive or tiring, which would not be a risk for a special interest because you'd want to be doing those things anyway even if they are expensive and tiring, this sounds very much like casually trying things out.

The book appears to have some good advice on things like how to not accidentally harass people, but a mixture of good and terrible advice aimed at people who will have difficulty telling the two apart doesn't have many advantages over no advice at all as there's already plenty of variable quality advice with no indicator how good it is out there.