For me, it depends on the person. I had one ex who loved makeup and she'd go all out with it. She knew how to do stage makeup as well as day to day styles. She had a blast putting it on and would go all out with it (it was a form of creative self expression to her) and then she felt like amazing once it was on. For her, I preferred it due to how it made her feel. Another of my ex's hated makeup. She was the queen of waking up in the morning and going out as is. She'd grin at me after maybe running a brush through her hair and say, "Yeah, I wake up looking this good." I would have preferred she not wear any because she felt amazing without it. I don't care one way or another about how the stuff looks on a person, I care about how it makes them feel. If they like it, great. If not, great.