Asperger's in Naruto (I'm serious!)

Post Reply New Topic

You're glorifying yourselves a bit too much by saying that everyone that is awesome shares properties with yourselves. Name droppers, much?

Oh, I've seen Sai in the most recent American Shonen Jumps.

I would consider him Aspie IF his profile said nothing about the fact that he was "trained" to be "emotionless and solitary." Other than that, I would agree.

I just like Sai's ability ... he freaking bring his drawing to life.

So cool!

But yeah i certainly see similarities.

but for me I have always related to Shikamaru the most. He is just like me especially in school. I was and still am the one who is always bored and laying outside int he grass yet when it comes to things like leadership training i am first to command and always get the job done... also i live by a motto : Path of least resistance

I've actually been thinking this too for a while.
I wouldn't say he is (because he isn't real, and so cannot possess a real mental abnormality if the characterization does not explicitly state that he does), but I would say that he is an excellent example of autistic behavior.
My three favorite characters in this series are Gaara, Hinata, and Sai, mainly because of their similarities to autistic behavior.

To enforce the "Autistic Hinata" argument- she has had her bouts of obsessiveness toward her training and Naruto.
To enforce the "Autistic Sai" argument- one of those books he was reading was a manga- something that should not be taken at face-value, but he gullibly trusted the author to portray a realistic example. After seeing this, Sakura made the comment, "You really do take everything at face value, don't you?"

Sai was trained to be that way, therefore it was a social conditioning.

You don't train to be autistic.

Since it apparently wasn't clear, I'd like to explain my argument for Hinata.
If you've read this article, http://www.wrongplanet.net/article352.html you know that infatuation and the autism-related OCD involve the same chemical.
Infatuation is still normal, but Hinata takes it to abnormal extremes.
Normally, infatuation would disappear once the infatuated person and the person the infatuation is for have been separated for a while.
Not the case for Hinata, who became even more infatuated with Naruto (if that's possible) for the two years that Naruto left the Leaf Village.
I see so many times the idea that girls with AS obsess over things that normal girls like (e.g. horses), but to such a higher degree (e.g. knowing all these details about horse social behavior). That is the case with Hinata, as explained above.
Also, you can see some distinct differences between Naruto's and Rock Lee's obsession with training, and Hinata's obsession with training.
Naruto and Rock Lee are very much excited about their training. Their emotions are gratified by their training. Hinata doesn't seem to have any emotional benefit whatsoever from her training. She is completely emotion-less and stoic, and she's still obsessed with it.

Again, I am not making the claim that Sai, Hinata, or Gaara have AS. I am simply claiming that they have similarities to AS traits.