Are my feelings justified or am I overreacting?

Post Reply New Topic

I have a friend whom I've known for a few years. I met her at the university I was attending and we became close (occassionally intimate) friends until she moved back to China. I would say we had a pretty good relationship for the most part and we'd always try our best to help each other with our problems, whether they were academic, work-related or social.

Anyway, we lost touch for over a year after she moved back but started talking again through social media over the last couple months. Turns out we had both been going through pretty dark times over the past year or so and were suffering from depression so we had a lot to talk about. We were talking nearly every day and had been discussing the possibility of visiting each other. I told her I had recently been considering visiting her since I missed her a lot and she said she she had considering moving back to Canada for a while since she missed me too (as well as her other friends and Canada in general). I was starting to make plans to go there (the plan was to stay with her for a couple weeks and then travel back to Canada together where she would stay at my apartment until she found a permanent place) but my plans got waylaid due to me needing to apply for a Chinese visa and then, of course, the Coronavirus.

We continued to keep in contact, however, and she kept telling me how much she liked me, possibly even more than a friend, and brought up the possibility of dating since she found me more attractive than before due to her perceiving me as different than what she remembered. She would also repeatedly bring up how lonely and bored she was there because of the virus and how excited she was to come here (even though she still needed a visa and wasn't sure when it would arrive).

Long story short, she told me on very short notice that she would be arriving in a couple days and that her friend would be picking her up at the airport but that I could meet her there too if I wanted. Unfortunately, her friend ended up bailing on her because she was nervous about getting infected so it was just me meeting her at the airport and taking the bus and subway back to my place. Problem was, once she saw my place, she said she didn't want to stay there anymore. She claimed it was too messy, that she couldn't breathe (it's a basement so it gets a bit mildewy but I'm so used to it I don't notice anymore), that it was like a cave (idk, low ceilings perhaps), that she didn't like anything about it and wouldn't be able to live there no matter what. As well, I didn't have a bed for her yet due to the short notice and the fact that it would need to be delivered but she had told me earlier that she was ok with it since I'd still be able to make other accommodations. I told her I'd be able to make modifications to the place to better accommodate her (though, tbh, there's only so many changes that can be made) but she still refused and said it would be impossible, and started searching online for other places to stay.

I felt very hurt and offended by this sudden turn in events and immediately became sullen and withdrawn (which I tend to do when things of this nature occur). After realizing that it might be more difficult than she expected to find a place in just one night, she asked if she could stay at my place that night but I was so taken aback by what she said earlier that I said I didn't feel comfortable with her staying over if that's the way she felt. I later took it back when I saw how much difficulty she was having finding something and said she could stay but she kept saying it was ok because she didn't want to make me uncomfortable. It also bothered me that she called her friend up shortly after and told her repeatedly that she was off to a bad start because she had "no place to stay", eventhough I kind of knew what she meant. She eventually found a place and I ended up paying for an Uber to pick her up since she didn't have a bank card yet.

So the question now is whether I was justified in my feelings or if I overreacted. I know she had the right to refuse to stay at my place but I was still shocked and now I have negative feelings towards her. Considering how much I had been helping her with emotional support, helped get her visa by writing a letter and paying her fingerprinting fee when she said her card didn't work (though she did pay me back after I reminded her about it), putting her up at my place and offering to buy her a bed, etc., I felt kind of used and taken advantage of. It also doesn't help that every place she stays at, the landlord has a no visitors policy (this is literally like the fifth time already since I've known her) and even though I've explained to her multiple times that it's literally illegal for a landlord to do that, she doesn't seem to care. So, basically every time we meet (if) it would have to be in public- can't watch tv, listen to music, have any private time- which is very different from how I thought it would be.

Last time she was here, I was frustrated that I didn't have my own place (I was still at my parents') and believed that it got in the way of us having a closer relationship. Now, it's like nothing has changed. Sometimes I feel regretful for not having gone to visit her when she offered to let me stay at her place, virus or not (the outbreak was very low in her region and I have a very strong immune system anyway); I keep thinking maybe things would've turned out differently but I guess I can't prove anything now.

*Of course, there's also the possibility that she was simply using me to get her Canadian visa (it's not exactly the first time this has happened with someone but the first case was a little more complicated and ambiguous) and that now she doesn't need me anymore so doesn't have any need to stay with me, which she may consider an imposition. I mean, one of the first things she mentioned to me when I contacted her was how much she had been wanting to come back to Canada and later admitted that she tried earlier but wasn't allowed. But I'd rather not have to draw that conclusion.

Well, if she’s been longing to return to Canada and all her friends (including you) then she’s probably been daydreaming to a certain extent of how great it will be.
Being confronted with a cellar apartment with a bit of disrepair and in need of a little tidying after a long, tiring flight was probably disappointing: which is natural.

And on your side, you’ve been looking forward to your friend returning, even having hopes of possible romance: her disappointment & tiredness will naturally have been hurtful for you, particularly when you’ve been willing to improvise outside of your tenancy contract to make her move possible.

Not the best start it’s true, but a little calm honesty, compassion and forgiveness for hurt feelings should smooth it over.

As far as the ”using for immigration” theme goes, it’s not impossible, but it is natural to turn to your friends for help when enacting such a massive life change: I’d err on the side of generosity of spirit on that one.
If she really was out to use you for a visa, she probably wouldn’t have risked offending you by being honest about her disappointment.

File the thought away carefully, but don’t dwell on it. Then do what you can to mend hurt feelings and enjoy your friend.

i do not immediately sense emigration, but somewhat you weren't the nbr one destiny
depending how you steer the conversation and with the interpretation of flattering statements that might not mean much, but a form of politeness, taken too personal

in the neutral light of accomodating a traveller, bringing her to your place was a mistake, then there's not even a bed, what would you expect she'd think of that

making a reservation at a place to stay the night would've been appropriate

better luck in the future

I see it from a different perspective, a less benevolent one. Lady wants desperately to escape the Corona virus and all its restrictive implications. She took advantage of your help which was enormous, providing a visa, enabling her to enter Canada without forced quarantine ( she wouldn't have been admitted to my country at all.) A roof over her head ( massive help for heavens sake, with her coming from the den of Corona)
You have provided refuge. She has given you false romantic hopes and is completely devoid of gratitude for the risks (yes) you have taken and the lengths you have gone to assist her. Ungrateful, rude, spoilt, insensitive perhaps she is even manipulating this whole escape fron . In the NT world she would have been politely or impolitely shown the door for her total lack of appreciation and rudeness, this is, after all your home and she is throwing your hospitality back in your face. I would have checked her in to a hotel at her expense. Not worthy of your love, admiration or kindness in my view.

Edit: half this post will not appear for some reason. Escape from the sickness and quarantine, should be. If its back then consider this double emphasis.

Completely justified, but please don't be too hard on her, either. There might be some cultural differences at the picture and you did say you've both had it hard recently, right? She's probably under a lot of stress.

Of course, the possibility that she is using you also exists. Don't do anything hasty, but keep it in mind when you interract with her. If she has the habit of contacting you when she needs something but not any other time then that's a bad sign.

It's difficult to say who is right and wrong, because we can see only your thoughts and feelings.
Whether she used you or not, I cannot really say. But one thing what nobody mentioned in this thread yet: when you are desperate, lonely, depressed etc and someone reach out for you, I think many people tend to idolize that person and start to develop romantic feelings (girls at least very often do that, you know the typical "hero who saved me"). There is nothing wrong with that, but the reality can be different i.e. when you finally meet.
Also seeing someone and something via webcam is so different. Even if you guys knew each other before. Whether she liked your apartment before entering or not, and changed her mind when seeing and smelling in live - only she can say that. Messy indeed means different for people, I remember when I visited a friend who said he just tidied up and his whole flat looked like some nomad family would camp over there, big piles of clothes, magazines, objects everywhere.

Answering your question: she was still impolite or maybe even hysteric. If you come on a short notice and someone invites you to his place it's very rude to express your feelings with these words. I would have been offended the same way like you were. And my reaction would have been the same, because she hurt my pride.
At the end you both hurt the other (yes, she started it)
And yes, probably she was and is very stressed out. Let her calm down a bit and try to talk to her again some later time. Maybe she really didn't like something in your flat or she remembered you as a different man (webcam truly distorts things) look wise, but too polite to mention that.

Hope this story will have a happy ending

I guess if I was going to give any advice it would be, "Walk with eyes wide open".

The first thing that entered my thoughts was "Is she a carrier?" Does she have the coronavirus?

I suspect that her visa was predicated on you providing her support during her stay. Refusing to stay with you upon her arrival is rude but it also seems to break this governmental commitment.