I know how you feel. There really isn't any magic situation that you can get into where you will automatically make friends. Even in a club (where you would think the task would be easier). In my situation the problems stems from a different set of priorities. I tend to judge my compatibility with others on our common intelligence level, interests, and temperament. I'm lead to believe that other people tend to put more emphasis on looks, body language, and sociability. Failing their checklist is usually the end of the story. Rarely am I in a position to make the final judgement.