2022 Rock and Roll Hall of Fame Inductees

Page 1 of 1 [ 1 post ] 

ASPartOfMe
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 25 Aug 2013
Age: 67
Gender: Male
Posts: 36,257
Location: Long Island, New York

04 May 2022, 9:50 am

Duran Duran, Pat Benatar, Eminem, and a reluctant Dolly Parton among Rock & Roll Hall of Fame Class of 2022 inductees

Quote:
The Rock & Roll Hall of Fame's Class of 2022 has been announced, and among the inductees are five first-time nominees — including one who actually tried to turn down her nomination in the first place.

The first-time nominees getting inducted via the Performer category, which recognizes “artists who have created music whose originality, impact, and influence has changed the course of rock ‘n’ roll,” are new wave idols Duran Duran, hip-hop superstar Eminem (the only Class of 2022 artist to be inducted in a first year of eligibility), pop/soul veteran and American Idol judge Lionel Richie, singer-songwriter Carly Simon, and, most interestingly, country legend Dolly Parton. Previously nominated artists rounding out the Performer category are rock powerhouse Pat Benatar and synth duo the Eurythmics.

In March, a month after this year’s 17 Rock Hall nominees had been revealed, Parton shockingly and unprecedentedly announced that she was “respectfully” withdrawing from the ballot because she didn’t feel she had “earned that right” to be considered a rock artist.

However, on April 29, the Hall’s voting deadline date, Parton conducted an interview with NPR’s “Morning Edition” in which she seemed to soften on the matter. “It was always my belief that the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame was for the people in rock music. And I have found out” Parton revealed that if she did indeed make the Class of 2022, she would “accept gracefully” and “say thanks,” but she did not make it clear if she would attend or perform at the ceremony.

Metal titans Judas Priest did not get into the Hall this year via the Performer category, but they are receiving the Musical Excellence Award (which is given to “artists, musicians, songwriters, and producers whose originality and influence creating music have had a dramatic impact on music”), as are super-producers Jimmy Jam & Terry Lewis. Harry Belafonte and late folk/blues musician Elizabeth Cotten are receiving the Early Influence Award, while the Ahmet Ertegun Award, which recognizes industry professionals, will go to entertainment lawyer Allen Grubman, late Sugar Hill Records founder Sylvia Robinson, and Interscope Records/Beats mogul Jimmy Iovine. With the inclusion of Cotten and Robinson, this is the first year in Rock Hall history that six women will be inducted in one class.

In 2020, Rock & Roll Hall of Fame co-founder and Rolling Stone magnate Jann Wenner stepped down as chairman and was replaced by MTV co-founder John Sykes — a development that likely helped the long-snubbed Go-Go’s finally get into the Hall last year and boosted this year’s chances for other overlooked ‘80s artists, like Benatar (who was nominated in 2020 and led the fan vote, but was then shockingly snubbed), the Eurythmics, and especially Duran Duran. (All three of those acts were in the top five of the Hall’s fan vote this year, and Duran Duran in fact topped the fan vote by a 250,000 landslide.) In 2015, an anonymous insider disparagingly told Billboard that artists of the early-MTV era were viewed as “weird outcasts from England who wear mascara” by the Hall’s old guard.

“This diverse group of inductees each had a profound impact on the sound of youth culture and helped change the course of rock ‘n’ roll,” said Sykes said in a statement Wednesday morning. “Their music moved generations and influenced so many artists that followed.”


As I said previously the Rock and Roll Hall Fame should not have opened up to non rock and roll artists but this has been a lost cause for a looong time. Complaining about it at this time is virtue signaling. To me the legitimate choices are boycott or engage. Obviously I chose the latter. I judge should be in by talent(subjective), influence, innovation and length of career.

Eminem has had a successful, much praised career. When it comes to hip hop that genre is so not me I don’t feel right making a judgement. Dolly Parton has been humoungously successful for a very long time but I do not know enough about country music to judge her talent or know her influence on country music to make a judgement.

What I will roughly call “R&B balled” style that Lionel Ritchie sung as a member of the Commodores and as a solo artist while not my favorite genre is a style I have been listening to for over 50 years so I think I can make a judgement. The man advanced the genre, and over 40 years of listening to his music to say he meets the greatness criteria. Career length most definitely.

As a fellow Long Island baby boomer who plays the hard rock music I grew up with Benatar is a natural artist for me to root for. ‘Love is a Battlefield’ is an anthem, ‘Hell is for Children’ was way ahead of its time in dealing with child abuse. But she plays generic 70s hard rock. She plays it very well but to me just a tad short of great. So while a close call I have to very reluctantly say her induction was a mistake.

Now we come to two defining bands of the Second British Invasion(video, gender-bending, New wave, synthpop) that changed the face of rock and pop music. Duran Duran is a no brainer. Time has changed my and many others perspective. As I have explained I was a young adult at the time and new wave was a preview of sorts of my autism diagnosis showing me that others are different, ok with it, and other people actually like them for it. New wave remains my favorite genre. Duran Duran at the time to me were somewhat questionable. I liked but not loved them. They were the most commercial end of the New wave spectrum, the “Fab Five” for teen girls screaming for them, and the 80s version of the 60s Playboy man jet setting around the world with beautiful women. The opposite of who I am and what attracted me to New wave. Time has given me more knowledge of what they did and the ability to look at them objectively. They far from invented synthpop but sure did advance it in a major way both stylistically and popularity wise, a difficult thing to do. The same can be said of video music. They were heavily involved in the process.

A lot of what I just wrote about Duran Duran applies to the Eurythmics. Two things give me pause. Duran Duran is still going pretty strong, Eurythmics were a product of their era. No disrespect to Dave Stewart but it is Annie Lennox who has emerged as an iconic vocalist much more so then the Eurythmics has as a band. There are valid reasons Eurythmics deserve this honour but Lennox should have gone in first. If she had I could look at the Eurythmics case for induction more objectively.


_________________
Professionally Identified and joined WP August 26, 2013
DSM 5: Autism Spectrum Disorder, DSM IV: Aspergers Moderate Severity

“My autism is not a superpower. It also isn’t some kind of god-forsaken, endless fountain of suffering inflicted on my family. It’s just part of who I am as a person”. - Sara Luterman