TwilightPrincess wrote:
^ It’s such an impediment to progress. I guess we’re supposed to put humanism aside in favor of the “wisdom” of ancient people from a barbaric time? No thanks.
Humans are weird. We’re so smart - the smartest living creature we know of, yet we tend to cling to barbaric fairy tales, deluding ourselves into believing that they are moral, just, and inspired by a being we have no proof ever existed.
It’s scary what can happen when we put such nonsense above human reason and progress. Well, I guess we don’t have to imagine it.
There are times when I wish, with my whole heart, that I could believe in a god, with a plan and an interest in the events here on earth. Doesn't even have to be the cuddly, loving, beardy fellow forgiving my every misstep from his cloud throne in heaven. It's the idea that there is something bigger than us, that this isn't just some pointless random s**t that's happening. That there is a correct way to behave and a rightness and wrongness inherent in all things. That would be such a comfort. It's no mystery to me why people believe it.
I just can't. But I wish it. And the fact that I wish it is enough to make me suspicious about it. Because if I wish it, others probably do too. And humans tend to create what they wish for.
I'm equally scared by what happens when a society outgrows it's religion. When we have no shared moral guidance. Humanism is vulnerable to interpretation by...humans. Hence the need for an external moral arbiter. Real or imagined.
I don't think humans do terrible things because of religion, i think it's just one of many reasons that humans will use to justify acting terribly.
As for an impediment to progress, I'm not sure. And I don't know if it could ever be quantified. But progress happens from a solid footing. How are you supposed to move forwards if you can't agree where you are? You can't fire a cannon from a canoe. Shared values, agreed morals, a received set of inarguables - this seems to me like a necessary part of societal progress. Maybe the deterioration of that stability is why we find ourselves adrift in our time? Or maybe all times feel like that when you're in them.
Just thinking aloud. I have no faith, but I'm open to the idea that the mass rejection of faith is going to put society into a tailspin, maybe we're there already.
_________________
The world is a big place where things happen almost every day.