BobinPgh wrote:
I have a question for those in the know: Is singing a skill like swimming or tennis or is it a "gift". The choir director who rejected me insists that "matching pitches consistently" is a gift and I guess God decided not to give it to me.
I think some people are naturally gifted singers. My daughter once heard that a local little theatre was putting on “The Sound of Music” and wanted to audition. There were a Lot of other girls there with the same idea. There were girls who were gifted but untrained, there were girls who were well trained but not very gifted. And there were girls who were both well trained and gifted.
There were enough boys and girls (the director announced) to make three complete casts. But they only had room for one cast.
I think they picked the ones who were both talented and well trained. (My daughter was not one of those chosen).
I am sure many of them went on to sing in other things. My daughter was in many musicals in highschool but never in a lead part - she had an ok voice but had the unfortunate habit of choking in auditions. Her throat would actually close up on her when she auditioned because of nerves.
She sang beautifully in other groups. She had voice training in High school.
_________________
ADHD-I(diagnosed) ASD-HF(diagnosed)
RDOS scores - Aspie score 131/200 - neurotypical score 69/200 - very likely Aspie