0_equals_true wrote:
Every martial artist should know that pretty much every move has a counter, even ones that might seem infeasible. There is a big difference between drills and no holds bared fighting. Move in isolation a quite useless, you can't rely on set routines in a fight. That is why in Wing Chun the goal is to achieve
Fan Sao.
I was exactly like you when I was a beginner. I thought my teachers were indestructible. You won't have the slightest clue for a long time, just how good they are.
My teachers say they learn from the students all the time. Part of what make you better is the ability to question and analyse, not blindly follow. As one of my teachers put it quite aptly "Even Mike Tyson had a coach, it doesn't mean they would go 12 rounds with him". In other words teacher are there to help you get the best out of yourself, not just to impress you. Of course there are people better than my teachers, their master for one.
I get what you are saying about the limitations, however there are always going to be limitation, you just have to deal with it. You might be injured for instance. Ideally you want to get a skirmish over fast and decisively, but what if things don't pan out like that, do you have the stamina to continue?
Is this targeted at me? If so:
I understand fully every move has a counter. Some as you say are a little harder to do. I also think I know how good a few of my teachers have been (or not been) much better then you think. There is always somebody better.
Also I say I am a beginner for modesty. I have been doing Martial Arts on and off for about 3+ years now, and at various points when I was younger. I use beginner because I am not at a level were I see myself as anything other. However I can handle myself fine vs somebody untrained, and anyone on my level would be fair.
It also seems to me that you are hailing Wing Chun as the end all be all.