Fun to remember. There were no goths back then, just a congregation of the strange, so we shared across more music styles than goths would. I liked how my friend, guitarist in our band, would call us... We were an IDR band... "intense, depressive realism".
The bands I listened to would never be considered goth, but were much darker, I think. The OnlyOnes, Strangers, Suicide, Magazine, PIL, Vibrators, forgotten rebels, john foxx, robert fripp... later diamanda galas and concrete blonde
Now I have a penchant for cartoon goth. Listen to Tom Waits (a wonderfully dark old man) and publish academic articles on vampires in historical contexts. I used to co-edit and journal of dracula studies with my friend elizabeth (though that's her area).
By the time I was in my 20s, it was more fun to explore gothicism. I studied anti-enlightenment ideas from the 17th and 18th century... the poetry of william blake, and particularly Edward Young. Blake's Marriage of heaven and hell is particularly great because he believed that creative energy was closer to god than the rules of organized religion. And Young's "Night Thoughts (The Complaint: or Night-Thoughts on Life, Death & Immortality) is really the first great poem written at midnight, in storms, by the light of a candle burning in a human skull, while everyone around you is dead. Everyone else after blake and young were wannabies to me, back then, and I still admire their authenticity.
I used to tease the goths, especially when I became a prof., for not knowing where the ideas and thoughts that they were presenting came from, and missing the fact that who ever was popular at the moment was just coping someone even more interesting in the past.
I never dressed up to disrupt or confuse people. I did that no matter what I was wearing or doing. But I have always had an aspie's issues with colours and patterns on clothes, as well as the textures of cloths. I can only wear cotton... so black jeans of one brand and cut; only fluevog boots/shoes; dark or black clothes. But I try to add a bit of colour so as to not completely scare my students.
The good test of someone's gothiness is if they just give it up and change when they grow (then it is a fad or phase) or if it morphs and grows along with them, leaving little hints and markers behind.
_________________
diagnosed aspie and professor of stuff