I used to be popular in high school. Hard to explain. We had a very small school where everybody knew everybody. I was quiet and hung out with like-minded people, but good looks and money never dictated popularity in my school. A lot of people hated me too, naturally, but out of the 1000 kids that went to our school, I knew and was friendly with around 900 of them. I'd say there are about fifty faces I don't recognize in my yearbook and about fifty I do that didn't get along with me. You didn't have to be socially inclined in my school, thank god. There was no real blatant bullying except for five or six individuals that were grotesque to the point that it was almost unavoidable (like a kid who used to s**t his pants in high school).
Let me put it this way, I dated a football player who had Aspergers syndrome and was in the Gifted program at school. So our school was pretty backwards. slu*ty cheerleaders weren't very popular. Nice looking girls who took AP classes or college classes were, though. Gifted students were quite popular. Mentally handicapped kids in the Gateways program were also 'popular'. Nobody really made fun of them and everyone would bother to go down and volunteer, help out, high-five them in the hallway, help them in class, eat lunch with them, etc. So being 'popular' wasn't a fair assessment where I went.
If the question is, did I have any after school friends? No. I was only 'popular' while I was in school. Out of school, I had a handful of friends that I rarely hung out with.
If I was in a larger school like where my fiance went, I probably would not have been popular.