I've been told I'm unapproachable (also cold, rude, etc) also, but I'm a girl so it's a little different. People call girls unapproachable that look like they would reject guys, and (usually) people call guys unapproachable that look "creepy" in some way. That's mostly my opinion though, so try not to let it freak you out or anything
MarsCoban wrote:
I absolutely do not let girls I think are gorgeous know that I think that...I think I actually treat them as if they were ugly. I do it on purpose, because most pretty girls know they are pretty, and I feel like they expect me to think they are, which I don't like...so I act as if I thought they were nothing much, even if inside I'm going crazy for them. I think this may be a problem...
You seem to be very, very attractive from what I can see. If you don't show any positive signals to girls and even treat them like they're ugly, I think that's why people think you're unapproachable or "scary." There are girls that are extremely insecure and ones that just don't think they are that attractive (I mean, beauty is subjective) so they might be thinking they're unattractive and you're just being rude to them. I bet you there's been a girl out there that thought you were really attractive but was too unsure of herself to do anything about it and got the wrong signals from you.
_________________
After a time, you may find that having is not so pleasing a thing, after all, as wanting. It is not logical, but it is often true.
--Spock