Is religion always a deal breaker?

Post Reply New Topic

So, i'm very much non-religuos, and sometimes this can be a big factor in my dating life. I've been described as a chruch boy who doesn't like church...and that's fairly accurate.

Now my question is whether or not differing religuos views are a complete deal breaker in relationships. There's this cute lil' redhead girl, I know, that's so sweet and I'd like to ask her out, but....she's very religuos. I'd honestly being willing to ignore her religuos beliefs, but i could never be converted into believing such stuff myself. Though, in the chance it'd actually work out between us...well problems could be brought up in the future because of it. Sigh....Your thoughts?

Depends.

It's not about the religious beliefs, it's about how both of you choose to deal with them and whether you judge others who don't share your beliefs, on the basis of your beliefs.

If both of you are accepting and non-judgemental about religious beliefs or lack of them, then there will be no problem.

It will only become a problem if either she starts applying her standards to you (or if you do the same to her), and expecting, demanding or try to force the other person to change on that basis.

Most people are very judgemental and expecting when it comes to religious beliefs... and it often becomes a polarising issue.
If you leave the judgementalness out of the picture, things can work out very well.

I would make one suggestion...
Don't listen to Boo on this issue.

It depends on the level of passion.
Opposing views that are moderate are easier to reconcile than opposing views that are extreme.

I hit some roadbumps early on in my relationship because I'm largely ambivalent to religion and have some cultural spiritual beliefs that are important to me but I keep to myself.
The mister is a very vocal atheist.
It took awhile for it to sink in that non-belief isn't really worth talking about all the time (there are lots of book characters I don't think exist in real life, I don't lecture people about that). So now it's just something we don't talk about.

^^^
I think in many cases it does reflect the mindset, but not always. I know the effect you are on about though.

I think Kjas gave a great answer.

It doesn't sound like religion will be a deal breaker for you. Whether it is a deal breaker for your redhead friend depends on whether or not she's the type to create an account on OKCupid specifying that she's interested in a "good CHRISTIAN man" (I'm getting sick of seeing those profiles; why don't the theist move over to Christian Mingle?).

I think the only obvious issue I have with it is the lack of critical thought that the large majority put into it - thankfully there are exceptions to that.
If they are willing to admit that logically it isn't a very sound position, but they choose to believe in it anyway, well I am more than happy with that.
Naturally I would be interested in why they choose that particular belief and how it came about, but that is mostly from curiousity.
Differentiating logic and a belief is very important to me in that regard.