MagicKnight wrote:
Amebix wrote:
He strikes me as deeply damaged, like he's desperate to believe his own nonsense because it makes him feel special.
That could be true but I don't think we'll ever know for sure. Anyway he was connected to Maharishi at some point what makes both situations possible: he's been either one more "successful victim" of Maharishi like all the Transcendental Meditation celebrities we know of, or he was arranged with his mentor in a means to rip people off.
You're right that we can't know, but even if part of him knows he's ripping people off, I find it hard to imagine that he's cynically viewing it as purely a con. One comparable new age guru to both of them is Osho. I bring him up because Osho's been analyzed a lot, and many psychologists speculate that he suffered from narcissistic personality disorder. So even as Osho was spouting out half-baked nonsense he'd lifted from world religions, he likely truly believed in his own profundity, seeing himself as God's gift to man. It's harder to prove the shallowness of a spiritual leader when they're so delusional/insane that they sincerely believe in their own nonsense. What muddies things even more is the fact that these gurus aren't coming up with their philosophies out of nowhere - they're spouting out things that sound nice to them from world religions and philosophies, then mixing them up in a nonsensical stew. When they make connections from one religious idea to another unrelated one, even if it's contradictory, it's easy to imagine how they could trick themselves into thinking they've gained some special insight.
It's also easy to imagine how this sort of thing could spiral out of control: you have some mentally unstable person who's been reading up on philosophy and religion, then parroting it out, and they're intensely charismatic. The people who are most open to listening to them are people who are extremely vulnerable - people going through periods of transition, trauma, desperation, etc., and they're desperate to find some anchor, so they start following this guru. Before you know it, this mentally unstable person has a group of over 20 people hanging on their every word. The guru realizes that they're suddenly powerful, and all this praise feels really good. If they're having second thoughts, they also must realize that backing out would feel awful and be intensely shaming, so it's just easier to keep going with the con. I find it hard to believe a mentally healthy person would ever find themselves in that situation in the first place.