SocOfAutism wrote:
One of my students had PTSD, just could not fit in here despite what help everyone tried to give him, and eventually went into his former workplace and tried to kill a bunch of people. He did kill his boss and himself. I liked him and I wish he had not done that. I had another student who did not understand that when a woman says no she means no. I had to go to the police about that student. I have also had students from several different countries who might qualify as "black" be shocked and disgusted with Black Americans here. Why they are disgusted I am not sure- perhaps just seeing someone who looks like them but acts differently? But there is a definite reaction every time.
I think it is wise to be careful with who we invite to this country and how we do that. It ruins some people's lives to take them away from their home country. We need to make sure they will do well before we invite them to take that step.
One of our conservative foreign ministers in Australia used a report
https://www.abc.net.au/news/2007-10-04/ ... ews/689538to justify putting a halt to intake of all African refugees (particularly South Sudanese) due to lack of progress in assimilation and the propensity of young African men in Australia joining criminal gangs.
the wording he uses is remarkably similar to your post. Following his decision he was widely condemned for making some gross generalisations and accused of racism
https://www.smh.com.au/national/african ... -12mk.htmlA little digging into Mr Andrews and he had a laundry list of bias
https://www.smh.com.au/national/andrews ... -3ho0.htmlNot the first time Australia had to deal with this issue. When large numbers of Vietnamese refugees and Lebanese war refugees (most non-English speaking, unskilled and many having experienced war trauma) were taken in the 1970s, the public were vehemently against it. Many of the current criminal gangs today in Australia are indeed from these communities. But over time children learned to assimilate and are basically Aussies (Lebanese kids are practically indistinguishable from Greeks and Italians and Vietnamese kids are part of the highly successful east asian communities).
African kids have a harder time assimilating because they face more overt racism (not terribly shocking). So to overcome additional barriers it takes their community longer to assimilate. I think its a testimony to the South Sudanese community (Kevin Andrews worst fears) that the current generation are making great strides, I am seeing more of them in Universities and working in Melbourne (South Sudanese are easy to spot because they are incredibly tall and good looking). All they needed was a chance.
So being careful about which refugees get preferential treatment ignores both the challenges some groups face to overcome barriers that may be invisible to you as a volunteer but are real for them. It also ignores their humanity. We are all basically the same when you take away the superficial differences. Some refugees take longer because they have to overcome more barriers.
Carrying this type of thinking makes it easy to agree with the orange behemoth when he spouts nonsense about who he deems to be "good migrants". Of course he's going to make white south Africans a "damsels in distress" needing rescuing. If Kevin Andrews was alive today (he did pass away a few years ago) he would have agreed.