what i liked about games from the 8-bit/16-bit era was that in terms of serieses, every subsequent game was a quantum leap from the last game. Super Mario Bros is vastly different from Super Mario Bros 3, just like how Super Mario Bros 3 is vastly different from Super Mario World, and how Super Mario 64 is vastly different than all the previous ones.
when the Playstation era came around though, developers seemed content to remake the same game over and over. the Tomb Raider games sold huge for the console but they basically remade the same game five times. the Resident Evil games also sold huge but the differences between the first three games are extremely minimal. what's worse is i feel most of these games weren't even that great to begin with. they were just average. the reason i think they sold so well though is because of the integration of full motion video (which at the time was huge) and appealing to people who hadn't really played a lot of video games before, so these things seemed huge.
what's worse is that the innovators seem to think that this is the way to sell games now! Mario Galaxy was great but it didn't have the sense of wonder that seeing Mario in 3D the first time like Mario 64 did. Twilight Princess was good but it felt too much like Ocarina of Time. Say what you will about Wind Waker but it was miles away from Ocarina of Time, and if they'd made the sailing a little less tedious towards the end I think it would've gotten more praise.
what really disappoints me is when developers release an average to mediocre game, and if it sells well enough they don't see any reason to improve it. pretty much every 3D Sonic game has been s**t but they've sold well enough so why improve the horrible camera, the glitchy controls, and laughable story. there are certain franchises that had similar gameplay that with the sequels managed to make it just THAT MUCH better (MGS1-3, God of War 1 & 2) but these're few and far in-between.
_________________
OH GOODIE! - Three Chords in Three Panels
ohgoodie.net
NEVER NORMAL - Saving the World Between Sketchbooks
nevernormal.net