I LIKE it when girls approach me, first, especially if they're clearly smitten with me. I WANT to be wanted.
That is...if I actually like the girl. And that's the crux of it.
If the girl's a dumb, fat, overly giggly, ugly, and has nothing in common with me, then yeah I'm gonna be a little creeped.
Now, as for what I look for in a girl...this is not what I require, it's what I look for and find attractive:
-Appearance: Long crimson hair, gothic, black lipstick and eyeliner, pretty corset-dresses, slender and shapely figure, boobs (I'm sorry I just like them...lol)...
-Personality: Compassionate, weird, mature, selfless, honest, romantic, sexual (maybe a little perverted), sweet, intelligent, funny, creative/artistic, comforting, confident, sensual, seductive, idealistic but cynical....
-Other: In my general age range (18-25), we have a lot in common, we have similar taste in art and music. Loves Evanescence and Marilyn Manson type of music.
-Doesn't: Like BDSM, smoke, do drugs, practice any religion or spirituality, cheat, want kids.